Interest in the Baker Mayfield Rookie Card lineup is to be expected. He entered the NFL in 2018 as both a Heisman winner and the first overall pick in the draft. Being a quarterback, landing in Cleveland could have been seen as risky, given the revolving door the franchise has seen at the position for decades. But this time, things are different. There’s hope and excitement surrounding the Browns and Mayfield is leading the way.
Baker Mayfield Rookie Cards run throughout Panini’s 2018 football products. He has more than 30 RCs in the Beckett Price Guide, ranging from the relatively common and affordable all the way up to some that can run thousands. Understandably, it’s the autographs that fetch the most, but even in there collectors can find plenty of variety in card designs, presentation, themes and production numbers. Like most modern players, collectors and fans have plenty of choice when it comes to collecting the quarterback’s early cards.
Below is a breakdown of every Baker Mayfield Rookie Card ranked according to their value in the Beckett Price Guide. There’s also a full gallery so you can see what the cards look like as well as a list of their parallels.
Most Valuable Baker Mayfield Rookie Card Rankings
The following list includes Baker Mayfield cards marked with the RC tag in the Beckett Price Guide. These are 2018 base cards only. Inserts and parallels are not taken into account for the rankings.
35. 2018 Score Baker Mayfield Rookie Card #351
Parallels: Black, Gold, Green, Purple, Red, Scorecard, Showcase (/99), Gold Zone (/50), Artist’s Proof (/35), Red Zone (/20), First Down (/10), End Zone (/6), Gem Masters (1/1)
Buy on:
34. 2018 Panini Baker Mayfield Rookie Card #308
Parallels: Blue Knight, Bronze Knight, Silver Knight (/50), Gold Knight (/20), Black Knight (1/1)
Buy on:
33. 2018 Prestige Baker Mayfield Rookie Card #203
Parallels: Xtra Points Blue, Xtra Points Green, Xtra Points Purple, Xtra Points Red
Buy on:
32. 2018 Classics Baker Mayfield RC #208
Parallels: Premium Edition, Red Back (/299), Blue Back (/175), Premium Edition Red Back (/175), Timeless Tributes Gold (/99), Timeless Tributes Premium Edition Gold (/65), Blank Back (/50), Green Back (/40), Premium Edition Blank Back (/35), Timeless Tributes Orange (/25), Timeless Tributes Premium Edition Orange (/15), No Name (/10), Timeless Tributes Blue (/10), Full Name (/5), Premium Edition No Name (/5), Timeless Tributes Premium Edition Blue (/5), Premium Edition Full Name (1/1), Timeless Tributes Black (1/1), Timless Tributes Premium Edition Black (1/1)
Buy on:
31. 2018 Rookies and Stars Baker Mayfield Rookie Card #101
Parallels: Green, Purple, Red, Longevity (/75), True Blue (/49), Red and Blue (/25), Gold (/10), Black and Blue (/5), Platinum (1/1)
Buy on:
30. 2018 Select Baker Mayfield Rookie Card #30
Parallels: Prizm Silver, Prizm Zebra, Prizm Tri Color (/199), Prizm Blue (/175), Prizm Maroon (/99), Prizm White (/75), Prizm Orange (/49), Prizm Tie-Dye (/25), Prizm Gold (/10), Prizm Neon Orange Pulsar (/9), Prizm Green (/5), Prizm Black (1/1)
Buy on:
29. 2018 Elite Draft Picks Baker Mayfield Rookie Card #139
Parallels: Aspirations Orange, Status Die-Cut Orange, Aspirations Purple (/99), Status Die-Cut Purple (/99), Aspirations Red (/49), Status Die-Cut Red (/49), Aspirations Blue (/25), Status Die-Cut Blue (/25), Aspirations Gold (/10), Status Die-Cut Gold (/10), Aspirations Emerald (/5), Status Die-Cut Emerald (/5), Aspirations Teal (1/1), Status Die-Cut Teal (1/1)
Card has variation with Mayfield running.
Buy on:
28. 2018 Donruss Baker Mayfield RC #303
Parallels: Aqueous Test, Press Proof Blue, Press Proof Bronze, Press Proof Green, Press Proof Red, Press Proof Silver (/100), Season Stat Line (/99), Press Proof Silver Die-Cut (/75), Press Proof Gold (/50), Press Proof Gold Die-Cut (/25), Press Proof Black (/10), Jersey Number (/6), Press Proof Black Die-Cut (1/1)
Buy on:
27. 2018 Playoff Baker Mayfield RC #202
Parallels: Goal Line, Kickoff, Red Zone, 1st Down (/99), 2nd Down (/49), 3rd Down (/25), 4th Down (/10), Touchdown (1/1)
Buy on:
26. 2018 Panini Luminance Baker Mayfield RC #107
Parallels: Gold, Orange (/225), Blue (/99), Platinum Blue (/25), Red (/10), Pink (/5), Gun Metal (1/1)
Buy on:
25. 2018 Panini Unparalleled Baker Mayfield RC #208
Parallels: Flight, Galactic, Shine, Astral (/200), Superplaid (/150), Whirl (/100), Impact (/75), Hyper (/25), Fireworks (/5), Burst (1/1)
Buy on:
24. 2018 Panini Phoenix Baker Mayfield Rookie Card #106
Parallels: Color Burst, Red (/299), Pink (/199), Purple (/149), Orange (/99), Yellow (/75), Green (/25), Black (/10), Blue (1/1), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1)
Buy on:
23. 2018 Panini Playbook Baker Mayfield RC #128
Parallels: Bronze, Orange, Purple, Platinum (/49), Green (/25), Gold (/10), Red (1/1)
Buy on:
22. 2018 Elite Baker Mayfield RC #153 /399
Parallels: Green, Pink, Red (/199), Purple (/99), Aspirations (/94), Orange (/25), Aspirations Die-Cut (/24), Status Die-Cut (/24), Blue (/10), Status (/6), Gold (/5), Black (1/1)
Buy on:
21. 2018 Donruss Optic Baker Mayfield RC #153
Parallels: Bronze, Green Velocity, Holo, Pink, Red and Yellow, Teal Velocity, White Sparkle, Aqua (/299), Orange (/199), Blue (/149), Red (/99), Purple (/50), Black Velocity (/25), Purple Stars (/25), Gold (/10), Green (/5), Gold Vinyl (1/1)
Buy on:
20. 2018 Panini Prizm Baker Mayfield Rookie Card #201
Parallels: Prizms, Blue Prizms, Disco Prizms, Green Prizms, Lazer Prizms, Neon Green Pulsar Prizms, Pink Prizms, Red Prizms, Red/White/Blue Prizms, White Sparkle Prizms, Hyper Prizms (/275), Orange Prizms (/249), Light Blue Prizms (/199), Red Wave Prizms (/149), Blue Scope Prizms (/99), Green Crystal Prizms (/75), Purple Power Prizms (/49), Camo Prizms (/25), Gold Prizms (/10), Blue Shimmer Prizms (/9), Gold Vinyl Prizms (/5), Black Finite Prizms (1/1)
Buy on:
19. 2018 Panini Obsidian Baker Mayfield Rookie Card #103 /100
Parallels: Electric Etch Purple (/75), Electric Etch Orange (/50), Electric Etch Green (/25), Electric Etch Yellow (/10), Electric Etch Red (/5), Electric Etch White (1/1)
Buy on:
18. 2018 Panini Spectra Baker Mayfield Rookie Card #121 /99
Parallels: Neon Blue (/75), Neon Blue Die-Cut (/35), Neon Green (/30), Neon Green Die-Cut (/25), Neon Pink (/20), Neon Pink Die-Cut (/15), Neon Orange (/10), Neon Orange Die-Cut (/5), Neon Marble (/4), Nebula (/2), Gold (1/1)
Buy on:
17. 2018 Panini Elements Baker Mayfield RC Autograph #76 /99
Parallels: Gold (/25), Platinum (1/1)
Buy on:
16. 2018 Panini Origins Baker Mayfield RC Auto Patch #105
Parallels: Red (/75), Blue (/49), Turquoise (/25), Gold (/10), Green (/5), Black (1/1)
Buy on:
15. 2018 Panini Illusions Baker Mayfield RC Auto Jersey #102 /175
Parallels: Blue (/100), Red (/50), Green (/25), Purple (1/1)
Buy on:
14. 2018 Absolute Baker Mayfield RC Auto Triple Memorabilia #153 /399
Parallels: Spectrum (/99), Quad (/25), Quad Spectrum (/10), Five (/5), Five Spectrum (1/1)
Buy on:
13. 2018 Panini Xr Baker Mayfield RC Auto Triple Memorabilia #161 /25 – Redemption
Parallels: Red (/15), Blue (/10), Orange (/5), Gold (/3), Green (/2), Glove (1/1), Hat (1/1), Jacket (1/1), Laundry Tag NFL Shield (1/1), Laundry Tag NFLPA (1/1), Laundry Tag Nike Swoosh (1/1), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1), Prime Football (1/1), Super Prime (1/1)
Buy on:
12. 2018 Panini Gold Standard Baker Mayfield RC Auto Jersey #201 /99
Parallels: Prime (/25), Prime Tag (1/1)
Buy on:
11. 2018 Certified Baker Mayfield RC Auto Patch #206 /175
Parallels: Mirror Orange (/99), Mirror Red (/75), Mirror Blue (/50), Gold Etch (/25), Mirror Gold (/25), Purple Etch (/10), Mirror Purple (/10), Green Etch (/5), Mirror Green (/5), Black Etch (1/1), Mirror Black (1/1)
Buy on:
10. 2018 Panini Plates and Patches Baker Mayfield RC Auto Patch #232 /99
Parallels: Blue (/50), Green (/25), Gold (1/1), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1)
Buy on:
9. 2018 Immaculate Collection Baker Mayfield RC Auto Patch #101 /99
Parallels: Gold (/25), Emerald (/14), NFL Shield (1/1), Platinum (1/1)
Buy on:
8. 2018 Limited Baker Mayfield RC Auto Patch #101 /125
Parallels: Silver Spotlight (/75), Gold Spotlight (/50), Ruby Spotlight (/10), Emerald Spotlight (/5), Sapphire Spotlight (1/1)
Buy on:
7. 2018 Panini One Baker Mayfield RC Auto Patch #2 /199
Parallels: Blue (/99), Bronze (/49), Red (/25), Gold (/10), Platinum (/5), Black (1/1)
Buy on:
6. 2018 Panini Impeccable Baker Mayfield RC Auto Helmet/Patch #102 /75
Parallels: Helmet and Nameplate (/25), Helmet and Glove (/15), Dual NFL Logo (1/1)
Buy on:
5. 2018 Panini National Treasures Collegiate Baker Mayfield RC Auto Patch #105 /99
Parallels: Silver (/25), Gold (/10), Emerald (/5), Red Bowl Logo (/5, 3 different), Red Brand Logo (/2), Black (1/1), Red Conference Logo (1/1), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1)
Buy on:
4. Panini Flawless Baker Mayfield Rookie Card #101
Parallels: Sapphire (/15), Diamond (/10), Emerald (/5), Chocolate Diamond (/4), Canary Yellow Diamond (/3), Platinum (1/1)
Buy on:
3. 2018 Panini Contenders Optic Baker Mayfield RC Autograph #101
Parallels: Red (/99), Purple (/49), Orange (/25), Blue (/15), Gold (/10), Gold Vinyl (1/1), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1)
Buy on:
2. 2018 Panini Contenders Baker Mayfield RC Autograph #101
Parallels: Red Zone, Playoff Ticket (/99), Championship Ticket (/49), Cracked Ice (/24), Preview Autographs (/24), Clear Ticket (/10), Ticket Stub (/6), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1), Super Bowl Ticket (1/1)
Buy on:
1. 2018 Panini National Treasures Baker Mayfield RC Auto Patch #161 /99
Parallels: Holo Silver (/25), Midnight (/20), Stars and Stripes (/15), Holo Gold (/10), Green Jersey Number (/6), Black (/5), Stars and Stripes Premium (/3), Red Brand Logo (/2), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1), Red (1/1), Red Laundry Tag (1/1), Platinum NFL Shield (1/1)
Buy on:
why haven’t you rank the baker Mayfield panini tri vault rookie autographed cards . and not number 1 as the card is in many other sites…than k I look forward to your reply Greg Cohen
@Greg – As the article mentions, only base cards with the RC tag in the database are listed. The Tri Vault card you mentioned looks to be an insert.
I have a autograph prizmz baker Mayfield card panini RA-BM could u tell me what its worth
@Michele – The price guide can be accessed here (subscription required): https://www.beckett.com/search/?term=2018+prizm+baker+mayfield+autograph&year_start=2018