[ZSDOne]

I would so love to see him in say KC with some big WRs, great TE, and a great RB with couple good backups. Also they have a amazing defense, that can also show improvement in some places

You know that Kansas City has a record of that sort of thing - and it actually does make a lot of sense from a football sense given the offensive weapons there.

[Marinocollector]

I would rather take Manning for the last 5-6 years of his career than Andrew Luck for his whole career

Yeah, but the Colts have already had Manning for at least 4 of the last 5 or 6 years of Mannings career.

[dfcj1499]

It's a tough decision on Ersay's behalf. There is a pro's and con's list a mile long and I think you have to go with the new blood. But I believe that if Peyton returns at 100%, he'll have success with whoever he's with. I just dont think you can pass on Luck because with Peyton, you're not gonna get another chance at a QB like that because peytons gonna win games. Then what happens when Peyton retires? I couldnt take that risk. I'd go with Luck right now!

As far as him playing for another team, it kinda saddens me Could you imagine Kobe in another Uniform other than a Lakers uni?? Jeter not a Yankee?? Although Lebron made the transition and is doing well. Seeing him in a Heat uni isnt weird anymore. It just would be nice if a player like that retires with his original team. And he could stay in Indy if he wanted but he wont take the pay cut.

[Num1Monroefan]

If you only think he has another 1 maybe 2 years left you must be watching the wrong FB

[Sajman01]

This has always been the knock on a salary cap system.

I can't even think of the last great player to spend his entire career with just 1 team. Michael Strahan maybe?

[goodtricks]

KC, KC, KC........

[joe callahan13]

If you only think he has another 1 maybe 2 years left you must be watching the wrong FB

If you think he has 5 or 6 years left... I'll have what you're having, it sounds fun!

[the great 48]

Yeah, but the Colts have already had Manning for at least 4 of the last 5 or 6 years of Mannings career.

LOL, you hope anyway. Ole Marino gonna drop to #3 in most records if he plays any longer than that.
And the only way I see Peyton done in the next 2 years is if his neck doesnt hold up.
The Colts are done now though. I love all the Luck hype. I obviously cant say how good he will be but I doubt hes gonna help the Colts right away if ever. And I like him...
You cant take Peyton out, put Luck in and expect to return to a contender over night. But we shall see...

[all day baby]

I would so love to see him in say KC with some big WRs, great TE, and a great RB with couple good backups. Also they have a amazing defense, that can also show improvement in some places

So would I... Too bad KC has none of those things.

If you only think he has another 1 maybe 2 years left you must be watching the wrong FB

I am willing to lay money down that Peyton Manning will lose his next starting job before the end of the 2012 season, and will be out of football before 2013 ends due to his neck issues.

[rgf17]

someone will benefit from this one. and it wont be indy. not knocking luck but if anyone thinks truthfully he will come in and make this team and plaoff contender i would have to disagree. not that my opinion matters of course. but luck isnt the answer to the colts issues. well maybe it is just a different kind of luck (not the passer).