I'd probably hold off a while on all three.
The first I'd sell is Madrigal, but I'd do it right after his first taste of the majors. He's an excellent prospect, but he plays 2B and isn't going to hit for much - if any - power. He's raking at AA, and he's an OBP machine. He'll hit and he has an above average glove, but the lack of glamorous counting numbers and the non-premium position means after the initial hype dies down, the prices will likely drop.
Next up would be Rutschman. Sales are getting steam based on going #1, and he has the potential to be elite at his position. He just signed and will spend some time in the GCL before heading to short season A ball. If he performs at all this year, the hype will only increase. If he doesn't, it will only pause it, and not send it spiraling because he's got that potential. The only reason I wouldn't look to hang on until he hits MLB is that it's Elite, which don't get the respect they should.
As for Gorman - I'd hold. He's a ways off and just turned 19, but he's got good power and plays a "shinier" position. That could be one that in 2-3 years, even if you sold it for its current BV or slightly above, you'd likely have some seller's remorse.
The first I'd sell is Madrigal, but I'd do it right after his first taste of the majors. He's an excellent prospect, but he plays 2B and isn't going to hit for much - if any - power. He's raking at AA, and he's an OBP machine. He'll hit and he has an above average glove, but the lack of glamorous counting numbers and the non-premium position means after the initial hype dies down, the prices will likely drop.
Next up would be Rutschman. Sales are getting steam based on going #1, and he has the potential to be elite at his position. He just signed and will spend some time in the GCL before heading to short season A ball. If he performs at all this year, the hype will only increase. If he doesn't, it will only pause it, and not send it spiraling because he's got that potential. The only reason I wouldn't look to hang on until he hits MLB is that it's Elite, which don't get the respect they should.
As for Gorman - I'd hold. He's a ways off and just turned 19, but he's got good power and plays a "shinier" position. That could be one that in 2-3 years, even if you sold it for its current BV or slightly above, you'd likely have some seller's remorse.
