[giantfan270]

Possibly, but look at the right edge of this one. If any of them were "off" it was this.

Who knows what their thinking? I had one come back shaved on the last submission, re submitted it this time, and got a 9.

---

I did pretty well overall with my vintage.

1956 Ted Williams 4.5 (I was hoping for a 5 or 6. However, I was surprised to find out it's a "grey" back which is a little more scarce)

1958 Mickey Mantle 7 (Thought this would come back altered. Glad it didn't and very surprised by the 7!)
Left edge. It doesn't even look straight.


1959 Bart Starr 8 (What I hoped for)

1960 Mickey Mantle 2 (Pretty much a dead card in terms of value. This was a disappointment.)

1961 Mickey Mantle 7.5 (Much better than expected)

1969 Mickey Mantle 5 (Thought it might be a little better, but still good)

1986 Jerry Rice 8 (Solid grade. Pleased.)

2005 Topps Black Aaron Rodgers 9.5 (Happy)

2005 Topps Heritage Aaron Rodgers 9.5 (Happy)

2005 UD Rookie Debut Gold Spectrum 9.5 (Happy)

I still can't believe the 7 on the 58 Mantle All Star!

Congrats Curt. I was hoping you were going to be happy.