I'm more shocked by Sabathia's omission. Tied for the league-lead for wins and in top 15 for strikeouts with a 3 ERA in the AL... thought for sure he would have been picked.
Collecting Rank:
1) Sets
2) Yankees
3) Alex Rodriguez
4) Roy Halladay
5) Mario Encarnacion
6) Mr. Feeny
1) Sets
2) Yankees
3) Alex Rodriguez
4) Roy Halladay
5) Mario Encarnacion
6) Mr. Feeny