[charbs1111]

Take a step back as a collector and just look at the situation.

It's an unknown player with a hard-to-copy autograph that sells for $4. You have a member with a similar certified copy that has 99% likeness to the card in question.

I just can't fathom this being a fake.

And these are the most faked card by far during its era, thats why we are suspicious. Unknown player or not, if you can fake a card who's print run is as low as 10 with these red autos, and make thousands of them that sell for only $4, youve made a lot of money.