[samiamryan]

Each season, I change what I collect. One year it was a 6th round draft pick Tom Brandstater to get a feel for each set. Last year was Demaryius Thomas auto. Im getting bored with just Broncos so I started collecting QB autos. Todays and yesterdays greats. I think Im going to turn it into a top 50 QBs of all time. I figure it would be a tough set, but one that would be nice for a long time. Not like collecting rookies and they never amount to much.

What I neeed from you is the best, most accurate and up to date list of the top 50 QBs to play the game.

[chiefsncards275]

heres a top 25 http://bleacherreport.com/articles/32517...ime/page/2

[Marinoisking]

I hope you don't mind but I kinda stole your QB PC idea and am trying to put one together myself haha.
You are leaps and bounds ahead of me but I am getting there. lol

---

heres a top 25 http://bleacherreport.com/articles/32517...ime/page/2

Bleacher report comes up with some crazy stuff.

That is possibly the WORST top 25 list I have ever seen.

I am partial to Marino but putting him at 5 is redonkoulus
And Dan Fouts at 17?? Really? I dont see how this guy is not Top Ten on any list.

I really dont agree with more than 1 or2 of the rankings in that list.

How do you think they did Chiefs?

[samiamryan]

Nah, thats cool. It will be cool to see which dirrection out go and what we each come up with. We should start dualing threads or the same thread. In all honesty, I stole the idea from someone on here. I think his name was QBCollector or something like that.

@Cheifsncards, Im looking for top 50. Id probably be half way to the top 25 already, I think 50 would be a nice, season long challenge.

---

I hope you don't mind but I kinda stole your QB PC idea and am trying to put one together myself haha.
You are leaps and bounds ahead of me but I am getting there. lol

---

Bleacher report comes up with some crazy stuff.

That is possibly the WORST top 25 list I have ever seen.

I am partial to Marino but putting him at 5 is redonkoulus
And Dan Fouts at 17?? Really? I dont see how this guy is not Top Ten on any list.

I really dont agree with more than 1 or2 of the rankings in that list.

How do you think they did Chiefs?

Dont you love how one list could be dead on for one guy, and way way off for the next. I hate ones with "formulas" or based off stats. There is only one way to do a list and its based of what you see.

---

I like this one. Its kind of long, but good.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dVp-q-zHwiA

[chiefsncards275]

i just looked up top qaurterbacks of all time and that was the first thing that came up, just trying to help out

[samiamryan]

No problem. Much appreciated.

---

I like this list. Order isnt perfect, but the top 50 are solid.

[Marinoisking]

lets do it man....
You have a HUGEEEEE lead on me right now.
I just got a Dez Bryant auto patch prime /15
for trade bait on a qb auto so hopefully that will add one
I have 2 Peyton autos so I would like to trade one of them for another top guy

[bostonsports1]

Heres a good starting point, top 15

Joe Montana
Otto Graham
Johnny Unitas
John Elway
Brett Favre
Tom Brady
Peyton Manning
Terry Bradshaw
Dan Marino
Steve Young
Joe Namath
Troy Aikman
Bart Starr
Jim Kelly
Roger Staubach

[Marinoisking]

Dan Marino
Joe Montana
John Elway
Johhny Unitas
Peyton Manning
Brett Favre
Otto Graham
Dan Fouts
Joe Namath
Terry Bradshaw

That is my top 10 in order

[bakerman8419]

1. Dan Marino
2. Dan Marino
3. Dan Marino
4. Dan Marino
5. Dan Marino
6. Dan Marino
7. Dan Marino
8. Dan Marino
9. Joe Montana
10. Dan Marino
11. Dan Marino
12. Dan Marino
13. Peyton Manning
14. Dan Marino
15. Dan Marino
16. Dan Marino
17. Dan Marino
18. Dan Marino
19. Dan Marino
20. Dan Marino
21. Dan Marino
22. Dan Marino
23. Tom Brady
24. Dan Marino
25. Dan Marino
26. Dan Marino
27. Dan Marino
28. Dan Marino
29. Dan Marino
30. Dan Marino
31. Dan Marino
32. Brett Favre
33. Dan Marino
34. Dan Marino
35. Dan Marino
36. Dan Marino
37. Dan Marino
38. John Elway
39. Dan Marino
40. Dan Marino
41. Dan Marino
42. Dan Marino
43. Dan Marino
44. Dan Marino
45. Johnny Unitas
46. Dan Marino
47. Dan Marino
48. Dan Marino
49. Dan Marino
50. Dan Marino

This is the most accurate list ever produced.