[ricelynnevans75]

I believe you 100%, but people will still pay a preimum for Columbia and the Caddy (and BGS). Just because........

So what you're saying then is that BGS looks great and costs more, but is not as reliable?

---

Yeah, but they don't equal each other. I know of a guy that crossed PSA 9's and received BGS 8.5's & BGS 8's.

Don't forget that guy who crossed a PSA 8 and got a BGS 9.

Or this beauty. (I'll try to get a better/clearer scan tonight)

---

Well I know a guy that has a neighbor who has a friend who has a sister whose boss's pool guy crossed over BGS 9.5's and recieved PSA 8.5's and PSA 8's.

Yeah Supply and Demand is overrated.....i prefer the heresay method.

He's the guy who won't even tell me what card he had that was an SGC 100 that barely graded a BGS 9.5. I've asked him quite a few times but he never answers.

Broad general statements are apparently supposed to be taken as fact, especially when the person posting is so obviously biased.