(10-21-2011, 07:20 PM)ceocards Wrote: Not necessarily related to this thread or this list, but the reason feedback from other sites doesn't count here is there's no way to prove beyond the shadow of a doubt that the 'other' profiles are yours.
I could go to another site, find an account with good feedback and come here and claim that other account is me. For that reason, the only feedback that counts on Beckett.com is feedback received on Beckett.com.
This is exactly what I meant with my post! I was not trying to say that 'freeman...' is not a good trader or that he shouldn't be traded with. I was simply stating the facts listed in his BECKETT profile.
That doesn't mean I wouldn't be willing to trade with him, only that I would still ask him to ship 1st until he has gained my respect & trust. If I traded with him several times without a problem, I would be happy to recommend that he be added to the list.
There could be 15 members here that vouch for him to be on the list, BUT I will still ask him to ship first JUST b/c he has less than 20 completed trades/feedback here.