[nittany13]

If you do not mind cgod26, I would like to comment on your listings from your post. I thank you for taking the time to compile all this. My comments are in caps because I want to more easily differentiate our statements.

Napoleon Kaufman Lompoc High School Phone card.
THESE TWO PHONE CARDS ARE INTERESTING COLLECTIBLES, AND I ASSUME VERY RARE ITEMS AS WELL. I WOULD HAVE THESE LISTED.
1995 Classic NFL Rookies Die-Cuts #18 Silver Sig Series (Sample)
THE PROBLEM WITH INCLUDING THIS ONE IS THAT I AM NOT CERTAIN THAT THIS IS A LEGITIMATE PROMO. I STATE THAT BECAUSE I HAVE SEEN A NUMBER OF THESE EXAMPLES FROM VARIOUS CLASSIC SETS LISTED ONLINE WITH NO SERIAL NUMBER. SUBSEQUENTLY I AM NOW SEEING HAND-WRITTEN SAMPLE CARDS FROM THESE SAME CLASSIC SETS LISTED ONLINE. ARE YOU CERTAIN THAT THE SELLER DID NOT WRITE IN “SAMPLE’ HIM/HERSELF AND THEN SELL IT? IT SEEMS A LITTLE SUSPECT TO ME.
1995 Score RC #271 (Promo) ( I believe all players were produced)
THIS WAS DISCUSSED SOMEWHERE EARLIER IN THIS THREAD MORE THAN ONCE. I ORIGINALLY SCANNED THE KERRY COLLINS ONE ON ONE OF THE FIRST THREAD PAGES, AND THAT ONE HAS SINCE BEEN INCLUDED IN TO THE OPG. SINCE THEN I AM NOW INCLINED TO BELIEVE THAT THESE PROMOTIONAL SCORE CARDS EXIST FOR EVERY CARD OF THIS SET AS WELL.
1995 SP Prospects RC #17 (National Convention 1 of 1)
THESE DO NOT APPEAR TO HAVE BEEN STAMPED BY UPPER DECK, HENCE I WOULD NOT INCLUDE THESE IN THE OPG. THIS IS ONE OF MANY EXAMPLES OUT THERE OF CARDS THAT HAVE BEEN STAMPED BY THE SHOW PROMOTERS WHICH IN TURN ARE PROMOTED AS UNIQUE VALUABLE COLLECTIBLES, BUT THEY ARE NOT. I REMEMBER READING OTHER THREADS ON THIS SITE OF SOMEONE SHOWING A SCAN OF ONE OF THESE TYPES OF 1/1 CARDS BELIEVING THAT THEY PURCHASED SOMETHING VALUABLE, WHICH INDEED IS NOT REALLY TRUE. I JUST HOPE THAT NO ONE IS PAYING TOP DOLLAR FOR ANY OF THESE, UNLESS OF COURSE ONE ALREADY KNOWS WHAT THE STORY IS BEHIND ONE OF THESE SPECIALTY STAMPED CARDS GOING IN.
1995 Summit Chase Program Checklist #7
TECHNICALLY THIS CARD IS ALREADY LISTED IN THE OPG AS # 200 FOR THE SUMMIT FOOTBALL CARD SET. IF YOU TYPE IN “1995 SUMMIT FOOTBALL” YOU WILL SEE IT LISTED. HOWEVER THIS IS ONE OF THESE CASES WHERE THE CARD WILL NOT BE LISTED UNDER THE INDIVIDUAL PLAYER CHECKLIST, HENCE THE UNDERSTANDABLE CONFUSION. THERE ARE OTHER EXAMPLES OF THIS ISSUE FOR OTHER CARDS AS WELL AND IN EACH CASE IT NEEDS TO BE FIXED. ALL THIS TIME I DID NOT KNOW THAT KYLE BRADY APPEARS ON THIS CHECKLIST CARD FOR REASONS I JUST PROVIDED.
1997 Absolute Pennant Autographs #A6 (No Autograph) (This non auto was also distributed.)
BEFORE LOOKING THIS INFORMATION UP I NEVER KNEW PRIOR THAT 7 OF THESE 200 PENNANTS WERE DISTRIBUTED IN AN AUTOGRAPHED FORM. IF THEY WERE ALSO DISTRIBUTED IN A NON-AUTOGRAPHED FORM THEN THOSE SHOULD ALSO BE LISTED AS WELL. MAYBE JEPHTHAH1 KNOWS ABOUT THIS NON-AUTO EXAMPLE AS WELL SINCE ALSTOTT IS 1 OF THE AFOREMENTIONED 7.

1997 Upper Deck Mini #29
WHAT NO1DOLPHAN TYPED IS WHAT I WOULD HAVE STATED. IT IS LISTED UNDER “1996 UPPER DECK MINI”. THESE ARE MIS-LABELED BECAUSE IT CLEARLY IS A MINI COLLECTOR’S CHOICE CARD. THESE WERE KNOWN AS CARDZILLIONS AND WERE DISTRIBUTED AT A NATIONAL TOY STORE VENDING MACHINE, OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. THERE WAS A 1996 AND 1997 SET THAT WERE RELEASED WAY BACK WHEN. I BELIEVE JADEROCK ACTUALLY BROUGHT THESE TO LIGHT IN ONE OF THE EARLIER POSTS IN THIS THREAD. SCAN THROUGH THE EARLIER PAGES OF THIS THREAD IF YOU WANT TO FIND OUT MORE INFORMATION ON THEM.
1998 Collectors Edge Advantage Memorable Moments #NK-9 (Media Sample)
I AM NOT FAMILIAR WITH THESE SO I CANNOT COMMENT.
1998 Collectors Edge Masters #124 Silver (Preview)
(Many other players were produced as preview cards in the silver and gold version)
THERE ARE A LOT OF CE PREVIEW CARDS OUT THERE FROM VARIOUS SETS, BUT MORE SO FROM THE MASTER SERIES ONES SEEMINGLY. SOME ARE LISTED WHILE OTHERS ARE NOT. THE ONLY CHALLENGE IS DETERMINING WHICH PLAYER CARDS HAVE SAMPLE VARIATIONS – SOME, MOST, ARE ALL FROM A SPECIFIC SET? I AM OF THE BELIEF THAT ANY CARD STAMPED WITH A “PREVIEW”, “SAMPLE”, “PROMO” OR WHATEVER BY THE COMPANY THAT MANUFACTURED THE CARD SHOULD BE LISTED IN THE OPG.
1998 Collectors Edge Odyssey #182 (Hologold) (#ed 150)
THIS IS AN INTERESTING CATCH. THE JURY IS STILL OUT ON HOW I FEEL ABOUT IT THOUGH.
2001 Quantum Leaf #135 (Promo)
(I believe all regualr cards in this set were produced as a promo. Hundreds are currently listed on Ebay)
A LOT OF THESE PROMO VERSION CARDS MANUFACTURED BY DONRUSS/LEAF/PLAYOFF FROM 2000 AND 2001 HAVE INUNDATED THE EBAY PAGES WITHIN THE PAST YEAR. I AND ANOTHER MEMBER DISCUSSED THIS AS WELL ON ONE OF THE RECENT PAGES OF THIS THREAD.

I ALSO NOTICED THAT YOU LISTED SOME ITEMS THAT ARE IN THE OPG THAT YOU QUESTION THE EXISTENCE OF. I ACTUALLY STARTED A SPIN-OFF THREAD ABOUT THIS SOME TIME AGO THAT MIGHT INTEREST YOU:
http://www.beckett.com/forums/thread-155...ight=25%2B

YOU WILL FIND THAT I AGREE WITH YOU FOR THE MOST PART.
1997 Fleer Checklist #447 (Crystal Silver)
1997 Fleer Checklist #447 (Tiffany Blue)
I AGREE THAT ALL FIVE CHECKLISTS DO NOT HAVE PARALLELS.
1997 Pinnacle Certified Napoleon Kaufman #46 (Promos)
I ALSO BELIEVE THAT ONLY THREE OF THESE PROMOS EXIST.
1999 Collectors Edge Advantage Millennium Collection #115 (Blue)
THIS ONE IS AN INTERESTING THEORY THAT I NEVER CONSIDERED. I NEED TO LOOK IN TO THIS ONE A LITTLE MORE CLOSELY. I AM NOT IN AGREEMENT YET THOUGH.
1997 Ultra #137 Brown Backs
AGREED.