The stars have been intermittent at best lately. Probably still working out the programming bugs of whatever it takes to bump them to the top. If you don't see stars where you believe you should, back out, refresh, and try again. Seems to help.
Mike Piazza supercollector: 4,267 different Beckett items
Also collecting John Franco, Eric Karros, Al Leiter, Brandon Nimmo, Todd Pratt, Robin Ventura, Turk Wendell, and Todd Zeile
Also collecting John Franco, Eric Karros, Al Leiter, Brandon Nimmo, Todd Pratt, Robin Ventura, Turk Wendell, and Todd Zeile