I guess for me it depends on whether you care about the card you're supposed to get. For example, I would request replacement on the Joe Adams stuff at least and probably the Hiltons and the Jimmy Smith. You might get something better instead (although that's all a matter of opinion). I once got a Theismann auto instead of Russell Okung. Better for me, but there are Seahawks collectors that might rather have the Okung...
Banner by mattfastiggi
Collecting: Brett Favre (7,771 unique as of 6/1/2015), Packers, UW Huskies (Shaq Thompson, Shelton, Peters, Kikaha, Sankey, ASJ, Trufant, Locker, Brunell, Dillon, etc.)