[rare23air83]

If you're really picky, do it. It will make you feel much better knowing you have a solid BGS 9.5 but if you REALLY want to upgrade the card, I would sell your BGS 9.5 copy and try to obtain a PSA 10 copy as those are more coveted and sought after than BGS 9.5 RC's. Those have more potential to hold value than BGS 9.5 copies. At least that's what the market has shown for several years.