I have umped before, and the rule says it is a ball that can be caught by an infeilder without extraordinary effert, aka a routine pop fly. There is no mention of the ball having to be in the infeild. I agree with the actual call, however it was poorly exicuted and they should have called it way before they did.
Help me find the last one of these ^^^!!!
Bucket http://s873.photobucket.com/albums/ab292/20youksox
Current Youkilis Count:602/2117- 28.43%