I cant afford to buy a whole box so I dont know personally how you did; however I do know from other postings you did about average. I know I have been buying the singles of the Future/rookie phenoms off of ebay for around 7-15$ +s/h. But the Reggie Jackson could fetch you a fair price. IRT not finding the card on Beckett, from what I understand Brian Flescher hasnt gotten a complete checklist of the product and hasnt priced everything (at least that is what I gathered from the TTT box busters).
If you start your day saying how it is going to be awesome, it is more than likely going to be disappointing, but if you are Awesome than it is hard not to have an Awesome day.