[philc80]

Hey guys, I just got back into collecting (haven’t since I was a kid), and I’ve been on the hunt for Tom Brady rookie cards and tend to favor BGS 9.5 (subs all 9.5 and at least one 10 for centering or corners). Would you guys prefer a 9.5 with these subgrades or a PSA 10? It appears PSA 10s are selling faster and going for more than BGS 9.5s, but I am typically seeing subgrades of all 9.5 or worse. Despite the appeal of PSA 10s, I just can’t seem to pull the trigger due to the movement of the card within the slab.

[dmasci]

I'm not a fan of PSA for exactly the reason you mentioned....their cases are just cheap looking and the cards tend to move around a bit.