[shezdoni]

Why Brady at 12 and not Staubach or Bradshaw or Stabler, honestly Bradshaw should get it more than either Rodgers or Brady.

#88: Alan Page over one of the greatest WR's ever Lynn Swann?

#17: Rivers over Richie Pettibon? Come on now

#23 hester over Troy Vincent?

---

#20 Barry Sanders may have rushed for more yards, Rocky Bleier played with most of his feet gone from a grenade in Nam after being shot in the leg, he played in constant pain, went out and gave it his all, that to me makes him better than Sanders.

[all day baby]

Lebeau... coaching in 6 Super Bowls and winning two puts him at the top over Riggins for me.

Coaching a Super Bowl has nothing to do with your play on the field. I vote for Riggins, because I know him from as far back as when he was in college.

I completely disagree with Shezdoni's last four points (seriously, Richie Pettibon?), but I can see the argument for Bradshaw.

[bakerman8419]

Why Brady at 12 and not Staubach or Bradshaw or Stabler, honestly Bradshaw should get it more than either Rodgers or Brady.

#88: Alan Page over one of the greatest WR's ever Lynn Swann?

#17: Rivers over Richie Pettibon? Come on now

#23 hester over Troy Vincent?

---

#20 Barry Sanders may have rushed for more yards, Rocky Bleier played with most of his feet gone from a grenade in Nam after being shot in the leg, he played in constant pain, went out and gave it his all, that to me makes him better than Sanders.

I think most people would say Tony Gonzalez is more deserving of #88 than Lynn Swan.

Brady will probably go down as the best QB of all time and no further than #2 on most lists behind Montana.

As for Richie Pettibon he was before my time and after doing a little research on him he sounded like a great player but Id still take Rivers. Rivers is already one of the best passers of all time imo and he is just now entering his prime. When its all said and done Rivers with be a HOFer.

Hester was HOF worthy after his first 4 seasons as being the greatest returner of all time. He has only played 6 seasons so far and has broken several records. Teams also have to consider Hester in their game plan because of how deadly he is returning the ball. How many times has a punter shanked the balls out of bounds for a 19 yard punt? How many times has Hester changed field position? How many times has Hester basically won the game for the Bears? Who returned the opening kickoff in the Super Bowl, Hester! Vincent while probably having the more consistent career and being a better CB then Hester is a WR he just never impacted the game like Hester has imo. If I were holding a draft Id take a solid corner over an average wide out but this isnt a draft. This is who was the best #23 and right now I feel its Hester.

And while I commend Rocky Bleier and his efforts on the football field and his service to our country, to compare him to Barry Sanders for what he did on the football field is a travesty!!! Barry Sanders is considered the best of all time in a lot of peoples eyes. I cant remember anyone suggesting Bleier is the best ever. The "#20" is Barry Sanders!!!

---

Coaching a Super Bowl has nothing to do with your play on the field. I vote for Riggins, because I know him from as far back as when he was in college.

I completely disagree with Shezdoni's last four points (seriously, Richie Pettibon?), but I can see the argument for Bradshaw.

Im thinking of sticking with Riggins. Perhaps it was the influence that I got from my Dad but he would always tell me how good Riggins was back in the day. Lebeau IMO is more remembered for being a great defensive minded coach rather than player. Maybe thats because he played way back in the day or because he is considered the best defensive coordinator of all time or both.

[mcleodfive]

I say riggins.

Also for #88 I would say Gonzalez. He is the BEST tight end ever to play the game! He changed the game to amore offensively minded IMO. Alan page wasent even the best at his position at the time. Not taking anything away from him because he had a great career.

[mattfastiggi]

I would have to GREATLY disagree that Brady will go down as the #2 QB of all time - I would love to see Brady taken out of Billi's system and see how he does. There's a reason Cassel has tanked out of being in that system.

As far as the debate, I'd have to go with Riggins as well as a player, Lebeau is an amazing minded coach, and a good player, just not the caliber of Riggins

[chads-cards]

im with lebeau...was lynn swann not an option for 88?

[ftballcardz]

#12 -- my pick would have been Bradshaw, but realistically it should be Namath. He was the NFL's first glamour/playboy. His persona was imitated by so many followin him... and he guaranteed a SB victory and followed thru with it.

#21 -- Deion Sanders, revolutionized the position from a pass defender to a touch down threat, plus add in the kick return threat.... one of the top 10 players All Time.

#44 -- Dick LeBeau ... All Time great at his position. Riggins was good but not at the same level when compared to his peers at the respective positions.

#88 --Tony Gonzalez ... Greatset TE to ever play, 11th ALL-TIME in receiving yards.

Just my 2 cents

[mcleodfive]

I agree with ftballcardz about Deion to. Can't forget Prime Time!

[robsvideos]

As much as i despise deion. I think a talented cornerback is rarer than a great running back.

[slotman11]

Keary Colbert at 83

Wes Welker buddy...