[elfeo013]

Would you rather buy a card that has 3 auto's (2 of them being future members of the HOF and the other auto being of a player that sucked and only lasted one season) or would you rather just buy a dual auto card (of the same 2 hall of famers in the previously mentioned card)?

Does the sucky player on the triple auto card lower the card value even though the other 2 will be in the HOF? Please let me know, thank you.

[d0dgerfan1979]

I don't think the one and done player helps your value, but I'd still prefer to stick with 2 HOF'ers. Seems like a more safe bet on holding the value.

[beginesj]

I rather go with the two HOFers!!

[PadresFan86]

Post the cards in question

[alfredoleal2001]

who are we talking about here?? lol

[bustin 5 knots]

I think the dual would sell higher (unless serial numbers are way different), but it depends who that player was on the triple auto. My only Joey Votto auto has Daric Barton on it, and he isn't exactly a household name but I'm an A's fan as well and he plays on the local AAA team, so I prefer it over a single Votto auto. So if the third guy was someone I like(d) then maybe I'd rather have the triple