[! #11 Roy Williams !]

Saw this on NFL Total Access earlier today.

They had the most overated player as being Roy Williams (Cowboys S)
Underated - Bullocks



Mine would be:
Overrated - Dallas Cowboys Safety Roy Williams!

Underated - DeMeco Ryans or Mario Williams

[premmy32]

Over-rated, TE SF49ers, forgot his name, Davis I think it is, shows how much of an impresion he is. Under-rated. CB oakland Raiders, ashmuoah, or so I think thats how you spell it.

[hector234]

premmy32 Wrote:Over-rated, TE SF49ers, forgot his name, Davis I think it is, shows how much of an impresion he is. Under-rated. CB oakland Raiders, ashmuoah, or so I think thats how you spell it.

Nnamdi Asomugha

[cowboysonly]

Roy Williams (S) can't be overrated because everyone knows he sucks. He does go to ProBowls but that doesn't really count because of how many clueless people vote for every player listed for their favorite team.

Overrated: Eli Manning - ok they won the Super Bowl. So did Dilfer. Overall the stats are pedestrian.

Underrated: Reggie Wayne or Marvin Harrison.

[G $MONEY$]

cowboysonly Wrote:Overrated: Eli Manning - ok they won the Super Bowl. So did Dilfer. Overall the stats are pedestrian.

Big difference, Dilfer's defense won him the SB, Eli won the SB for himself:!:

[geogn4t]

G $MONEY$ Wrote:

cowboysonly Wrote:Overrated: Eli Manning - ok they won the Super Bowl. So did Dilfer. Overall the stats are pedestrian.

Big difference, Dilfer's defense won him the SB, Eli won the SB for himself:!:

x2

[sweetsmelling15]

geogn4t Wrote:

G $MONEY$ Wrote:

cowboysonly Wrote:Overrated: Eli Manning - ok they won the Super Bowl. So did Dilfer. Overall the stats are pedestrian.

Big difference, Dilfer's defense won him the SB, Eli won the SB for himself:!:

x2

Ill have to say hold your self right there he can thank david tyree for his ring

[moxon4]

AFC-

Overrated- Vince Young
Underrated- Demeco Ryans ( looks like the next zach thomas)


NFC-

Overrated- Frank Gore
Underrated- Jeff Garcia ( never gets credit but plays his butt off when he is on the field)

[asornchai]

sweetsmelling15 Wrote:

geogn4t Wrote:

G $MONEY$ Wrote:

cowboysonly Wrote:Overrated: Eli Manning - ok they won the Super Bowl. So did Dilfer. Overall the stats are pedestrian.

Big difference, Dilfer's defense won him the SB, Eli won the SB for himself:!:

x2

Ill have to say hold your self right there he can thank david tyree for his ring

but what about the first td that put them ahead? sure tyree made an incredible catch but he had the poise to come from behind again....he played incredible throughout the playoffs and he shoudlnt even have had a turnover during the playoffs if it wasnt for smith's missed catch that fell intno hobbs hands (i even could have caught it) you can quote me if you want...last year wasn't a fluke, and Eli isn't overrated. There are many people that think last year was just "destiny". Wait till this year, he will prove that last year wasnt a one year wonder!!!

[sweetsmelling15]

We will see he looked like dog poop Against the vikings that was one of the worst games i have ever seen a QB play, if manning wants to become one of the elites he cant have one of those type of games, yea the first have TD but with out tyree would we even be talking about manning right now....just to say i was cherring big time for the giants not hating just saying my thoughts.