[tikitomoka]

! #11 Roy Williams ! Wrote:Not a Cowboy lover, but curious how Romo is overrated...

In the playoffs, maybe. Regular season, no. But, the last postseason loss wasn't because of Romo. Giants played good defense, and Romo fit one in to Crayton that I think would've put them ahead, but Crayton just dropped it. Not to mention, during the regular season, it's not like their defense carried them, nor did their running game. Their passing game scored the 30+ points. I think that is more of a anti-Cowboy pick, than an educational pick...

no its more of an educational pick

[gamebreaker]

Overrated: Tony Romo
I want see how he performs when injuried, like his elbow or such. He hasn't had a serious injury yet. I am not a Cowboys fan, neutral,
Sigh, Vince Young.. and I collect him.
The obvious choice, as well Reggie Bush.
Vernon Davis, got skills, personally think it is the dismal offense.



Underrated,: MJD, Fred Taylor, Fitzgerald and Boldin. D Mcallister, Warrick Dunn. Drew Brees.

[hnscholo]

OVERATED:
vince young
reggie bush
donovan mcnabb
kellen winslow jr.
derek anderson
jay cutler
tony romo
teddy bruschi

UNDERATED:
vincent jackson
jeff garcia
philip rivers
justin fargas
brady quinn
troy smith (what I saw he did pretty darn good filling in)

[bjavillonar]

broncoud13 Wrote:Overrated has to be Vince Young.

Underrated---several--but I think right now, Mario Williams...he is just starting to get a little credit, and deserves more.

also I would include reggie bush in the overated column.

I wouldn't say cutler is overated. Kid is going to be good so long as he can stay healthy.

[juke11]

overrated-current denver running backs

underratted-David Garrard

[! #11 Roy Williams !]

hnscholo Wrote:OVERATED:
vince young
reggie bush
donovan mcnabb
kellen winslow jr.
derek anderson
jay cutler
tony romo
teddy bruschi

UNDERATED:
vincent jackson
jeff garcia
philip rivers
justin fargas
brady quinn
troy smith (what I saw he did pretty darn good filling in)

How is Brady Quinn and Rivers underrated? Quinn hasn't played a game in the NFL, and Rivers is so inconsistent I don't think anyone expects anything of him... reason why LT has a difficult time running. Stack the box every play and make Rivers make a play.

[metallica103190]

Overrated: Vince Young, Reggie Bush

Underrated: DeMeco Ryans, Andre Johnson, Antonio Cromartie

[ryo1549(#1 David Thomas Collector)]

moxon4 Wrote:AFC-

Overrated- Vince Young
Underrated- Demeco Ryans ( looks like the next zach thomas)


NFC-

Overrated- Frank Gore
Underrated- Jeff Garcia ( never gets credit but plays his butt off when he is on the field)

How is Frank Gore overrated?!

[moellenb]

moxon4 Wrote:AFC-

Overrated- Vince Young
Underrated- Demeco Ryans ( looks like the next zach thomas)


NFC-

Overrated- Frank Gore
Underrated- Jeff Garcia ( never gets credit but plays his butt off when he is on the field)

[RBrown23 Dolphins ( Bravesndolphins )]

overrated - VY and Roy Williams

underrated - Andre Johnson and David Garrard