It's been my experience that with really low-numbered cards like that, they usually offer you "equal value" — which could be good (Pujols auto from a different product, maybe?), or not so good (five or six cards that add up to the same BV.)
I would be careful if you decide to request a replacement, just know exactly what you're getting before you agree to it ...
I would be careful if you decide to request a replacement, just know exactly what you're getting before you agree to it ...