(04-30-2013, 06:12 PM)evanturner12 Wrote: I offered a scan. He wants me to pay return shipping.
He also claims he shipped the card in a toploader with a plastic sleeve which he didn't.
Sure he wants you to pay shipping, but you don't have to. Like I have posted here several times. eBay is ALWAYS on the side of the buyer if there is a problem with the purchased item. If the seller wants the card back he has to refund your money AND pay for shipping. He doesn't want to do that so he is trying to get you to cover it.
I wouldn't do it. Keep the card and ask for half the money back or file a claim with ebay and get 100% of your money back and he pays return shipping.