Do you see on the reverse of the Jim Mcmahon card where is says "see also card #44"? There are rare versions that have the see also card #44 but does not have the traded stripe on the card front and also a version that has the traded banner on the front but does not have the see also card #. Hope this helps.
Cris Carter Collector 1660/2351
John Randle Collector 349/568
Pro Set Collector
http://s696.photobucket.com/albums/vv327...e%20Cards/