[Marinoisking]

I'm liking you more every post Marino to the people saying he had a bad game last game you're wrong. He had 3 int's yes but 1 was the receivers fault and one was basically a hail mary at the end of the game. Is he over rated or under rated who knows seems to me he's rated where he should be not the best and far from the worst.

haha thanks buddy...and yea I am pretty much with you on the issue....I dont think he is at the very top (although pretty close to it) but is farrr from the bottom....I would go as far as to say pretty far from the middle.

---

I, being a Giants fan, am a little biased but I think Eli is in that top tier of QBs in the league. If you look at this INTs alone, you won't be impressed with him; however, look at how many of his INTs are his fault. Especially last year, a lot of INTs came from deflected passes by Giants players. You could easily take 10 INTs away because of missed passes by his recievers.

I think Eli needs a bit of work, but he is definitely one of the better QBs in the league and definitely has some great years ahead of him with Nicks, Manningham and anyone else who decides they wanna catch passes for the Giants

Agreed....I already have him as one of the 50 best QB's to ever play....and by the end of his career I expect him to easily be in the top 20