10-10-2011, 02:10 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-10-2011, 02:13 AM by ejnfl24.)
RE: Eli Manning...how good is he?
RE: Eli Manning...how good is he?
(10-10-2011, 01:57 AM)Marinoisking Wrote: well I 100 percent agree with Sanchez...he is just awful....I think Ryan is a lot better than Sanchez tho...I think Ryan is def several notches under Eli either way tho.
I know a thousand people will hate on the list....but here is how I kinda rank current QB's...but Eli is the 3rd highest rated passer in the NFL through 5 games....ranked higher than names like Brees and rivers!
1. Peyton
2.Rodgers
3.Brady
4. Brees
5A. Eli
5B. Rivers
6.Schuab
Then after that I think it almost varries from week to week.
but guys that would be next in line would be names like
Vick,Ryan,Flacco,Romo,Hasselbeck,Roethlesburger,Stafford,Fitzpatrick...and those are in no particular order...just the guys that kinda bounce around in the top 15 and one guy that takes a lot of heat but actually plays well is Jason Campbell...he isnt a bad QB but is often looked at like a scrub
Eli might have a higher QB rating than Rivers at this point but he also hasn't directly cost his team win(s) against low tier teams *cough* Seahawks *cough*. Rivers has got off to a slow start but I'm sure 99.9% of people will take the guy in a heartbeat over Eli. He's going to turn it around soon and show why he's clearly the better QB than Eli.
(10-10-2011, 02:08 AM)Marinoisking Wrote: more so as of late?
He only has 2 interceptions in 5 games brosky.
He is the 3rd highest rated passer in the nfl this season.
You must be smoking that good good. He threw 3 INT's today and cost the Giants a win against the lowly Seahawks!!! He has 5 INT's on the season now. That's 30 total since the start of last season (which is where I was going with that comment). You mustn't know that ESPN doesn't update overall player and league stats until Monday/Tuesday.
