Opinions on grading please help! - Printable Version +- Beckett Message Boards (https://www.beckett.com/forums) +-- Forum: Hobby Talk (https://www.beckett.com/forums/forum-1.html) +--- Forum: Baseball (https://www.beckett.com/forums/forum-2.html) +--- Thread: Opinions on grading please help! (/thread-1503432.html) |
Opinions on grading please help! - chasescardcave - 06-13-2012 I usually don't get cards graded but because there's a special june offer, I thought why not. The viciedo and hultzen I am kind of unsure about because the viciedo have perfect corners, edges and centering, but has some minor surface scratches and one ding. The hultzen has 2 tiny dings and centering which I am not sure about. Here are the scans: Please give suggestions on all of them! The ding is a little low and left of the rc logo: RE: Opinions on grading please help! - mikecala98 - 06-13-2012 almost looks like the best one is the Hultzen. Rest are all OC or have too many flaws to reach 9.5. RE: Opinions on grading please help! - chasescardcave - 06-13-2012 (06-13-2012, 08:30 PM)mikecala98 Wrote: almost looks like the best one is the Hultzen. Rest are all OC or have too many flaws to reach 9.5.even the peavy? RE: Opinions on grading please help! - jasonmj - 06-13-2012 IMHO Peavy is off center top 55% to 45% and left 55% to right 45% depending on edges and surface probably going to get a 9. still nice looking cards.... RE: Opinions on grading please help! - chasescardcave - 06-13-2012 (06-13-2012, 09:23 PM)jasonmj Wrote: IMHO Peavy is off center top 55% to 45% and left 55% to right 45% depending on edges and surface probably going to get a 9. still nice looking cards....the corners and edges are pristine. so maybe I could get a 9.5? RE: Opinions on grading please help! - bustin 5 knots - 06-14-2012 The peavy looks pretty OC to me RE: Opinions on grading please help! - Haze28 - 06-14-2012 The left edge of the Sale looks flawed. Could be the scan though. The only one I personally would send in is the Hultzen. You might get lucky with the Peavy. RE: Opinions on grading please help! - mikecala98 - 06-14-2012 The Peavy could get a 9.5 if it gets a couple of 10 subs for corners and edges. Otherwise 9 overall. RE: Opinions on grading please help! - chasescardcave - 06-14-2012 (06-14-2012, 04:52 AM)Haze28 Wrote: The left edge of the Sale looks flawed. Could be the scan though. The only one I personally would send in is the Hultzen.yeah for some reason the scan of the sale made the whole left side look like it's chipped. RE: Opinions on grading please help! - nolan5000 - 06-14-2012 (06-13-2012, 08:30 PM)mikecala98 Wrote: almost looks like the best one is the Hultzen. Rest are all OC or have too many flaws to reach 9.5. The Hultzen even looks OC to me. |