Someday, I’ll have a Hall of Fame focus



By Chris Olds | Beckett Baseball Editor | Commentary

If you’ve collected for any amount of time, you’ve probably had the moment where you sit back, look at all of the hot mess that is your collection and wondered what your focus is.

Wait, it’s just me? Ok, I’ll go along with that … but we all know better.

As I pondered a column topic for an upcoming Beckett Baseball, I turned to the Hall of Fame — the simple idea of writing about notable sigs I don’t have. It was to be a woe-is-me approach — more like confession — of how I am lacking some notable signatures in my collection, particularly given my supposed collecting focus (well, at least one of them … one that has been around for a long, long time).

Instead, I actually surprised myself — while still realizing that, yes, I am lacking some notable sigs.

I’ve never focused on collecting autographs of baseball’s Hall of Famers — instead acquiring decent autographs at decent prices when they presented themselves, hunting sigs one old-fashioned way or finding autographs in packs. Years ago, that hunting meant trying for autographs of big names through the mail — baseball and otherwise — and, back then, it worked pretty well.

Between all sports — and non-sports, too, I easily have a few thousand sigs. Or at least it might seem that way. Besides being too undisciplined to intently focus on just one niche over a long period of time, I’m also not much of a sorter. My autographs and memorabilia cards are separate from other stuff but that’s it. (I’m missing that one “collecting gene” that must have everything in an orderly place.)

Despite my haphazard ways, I surprised myself when I quickly tallied my Hall of Fame autograph total, mentally checking off those I have and those I don’t. Again, despite never trying to actively seek out players, I have 41 of the 297 members of the Hall — mostly players but a couple of others. It’s a total that is far from Hall of Fame worthy — probably downright laughable for some of you Hall 0f Fame-focused fans with deeper pockets — but it’s a reflection of 25 years of having fun, moving from interest to interest within the hobby, not worrying about making  a buck. I collect for fun based on what I can afford.

Many of my Hall of Famers came via through-the-mail requests — guys like Richie Ashburn, Kirby Puckett and Eddie Mathews who often signed for the price of a stamp but are no longer here. Then there are the certifieds of the Hank Aarons (added just this year), Whitey Fords, Harmon Killebrews, Frank Robinsons (1994 Nabisco, baby!) and Barry Larkins of the world who I found inside packs or got via mail-in offers. That’s another way — perhaps the most-common way — I found them. Then, of course, there are the guys who I picked up on signed baseballs through the years — Nolan Ryan,  Steve Carlton, Paul Molitor, to name a few. That was before I realized I just don’t have the patience — or space — for storing a bunch of single-signed balls and the dangers of fading and leather blotches. Some of them came from the JCPenney Christmas catalog while others were picked up in trades with what went out of my collection long, long forgotten.

Oddly, though, none of my Hall of Famer autographs have been acquired in-person — perhaps a sign of how big the autograph industry has become during my collecting years (1987 to today). While I have met many a legend in other sports and gotten sigs in-person from some of them, oddly the sport I follow the most hasn’t created a moment. Well, unless, you count my recent encounter with Reggie Jackson — but all I got there was a single photograph and I wasn’t even thinking about ink.

The invention of the cut autograph allowed me to add a Joe DiMaggio sig straight from a pack a few years ago, but oddly he’s probably my least-favorite Yankees hitting legend of the bunch and yet the only autograph I have. Taking a different approach — winning a Twitter contest — allowed me to add a Goose Gossage autograph. (Not one I really ever would have sought out. I just got lucky.)

I’ll undoubtedly have more Hall of Famer autographs in my collection in the coming years as my generation’s stars are up for election — well, at least they’ll have a chance to be elected from the wreckage of the steroid era. Optimistically, my stats will look better with age even if I don’t add a single sig starting tomorrow.

Oh, and that confession part? Well, I’m a long-time A’s fan and I still haven’t tracked down a Rickey Henderson or a Reggie (not sure I would now). Other big names from modern times? Mickey Mantle? Nope, never forked over the cash. Bob Gibson? I should have — he’s too affordable considering his on-mound dominance. Cal Ripken Jr.? Nope — always wanted a signed 1989 Fleer Billy Ripken instead. Henderson will likely be next — but like much of my collecting habits, there’s not really a target item or date in sight.

Heck, here’s the biggest revelation of them all — the most-shocking thing I realized when I mentally worked through my Hall of Fame autograph collection.

I don’t even own a Bob Feller … and he signed everything.

Chris Olds is the editor of Beckett Baseball magazine. Have a comment, question or idea? Send an email to him at Follow him on Twitter by clicking here.


Tens of millions of cards available for sale in the
Beckett Marketplace!

Get up-to-date pricing for your favorite sports cards with a
Beckett OPG Subscription


  1. Randall 30 August, 2012 at 18:58

    I don’t have a refined focus on my collection. But I do go to card shows and pay to get HOFer’s signatures in person. I’ve never been very lucky at pulling HOF sigs out of packs. So I pay to get them. And most players are gracious enough to let my son get his picture taken with them. It’s worth it to me.

  2. Justin G 30 August, 2012 at 19:08

    I can totally relate to you Chris. I have been overwhelmed by my collection recently and I decided to start focusing on Hall of Fame Mem cards and Autos. I think the decision hit me when I got a Koufax jersey auto booklet. I work in pest control and whenever I treat my grandparents house my grandpa gives me cards. Last time he gave me Yogi Berra and Frank Robinson Collectors Edge autograph cards. Once I unload the rest of the collection I am going to get my Hall of Fame collection on the fast track. Good luck with yours Chris.

  3. Jamie 30 August, 2012 at 20:45

    I have pulled 21 HoF autos out of packs including 2 Roberto Alomars and 2 Whitey Fords…I would much rather pull an all-time great than a hot rookie any day. Much more satisfying to get a sweet pull than to stand in line for an auto IMO

  4. bill johnson 30 August, 2012 at 21:51

    reading this made me want to see the chris olds collection. thats quite a collection. ive collected auto’s from mets and jets players. my all time favorite met was the doctor, dwight gooden. i have almost 30 different auto’s from him. i was lucky to get a gary carter a few months before he passed.

  5. tuch 30 August, 2012 at 23:32

    My main focus in Ny Yankees in cards and autos. In the past year I have doubled both! I have 9 of the 32 Yankees including the manager in Auto. No super big names there. I have a majority of the 1951 and 1961 Yankees in auto including Mantle (Ball, Card and magazine photo) I have a large number of Hofer’s in Auto In the end it is about the item I have them Sign, wether it is a 25th anniversary Si magazine Summer of 68 signed By Denny and Gibson with stats or Monte Irvin signing a Postal Cover of the Negro leagues. It is the relationship to the item and the signer!

  6. kris 31 August, 2012 at 03:51

    my best pull was in 2000 topps got a golden anniversity auto of hank aaron out of a walmart jum bo.

  7. Simon 31 August, 2012 at 09:35

    Seriously though, my HOF collection has become the main focus of my collection. I’ve passed the 60 mark and am fast approaching 70 now. All certified baseball card autos, I too lack the room for balls and other mem. There’s something amazing about having a signature of someone who contributed so significantly to the game I love, many of whom have passed away, but the autos are a link to the past, and whenever I’m acquiring a new one, I learn all about what their contribution to the game was. Missing many of the biggest names (including DiMaggio), but have some pretty rare ones, like Clark Griffith, who started his playing career in 1891!!! Pulled that from a pack of Legendary Cuts – now that’s a piece of history. Thanks for the article Chris.

  8. Nathan Crandell 31 August, 2012 at 09:49

    Although my collection is no where near your size. I actually go for the autograph balls. I have 13 Atlanta braves Alumini signatures, to include Dale Murphy, from going to games on Sundays and getting autos from them. But all my autographs on balls ( I have about 16 with 28 autos, to include Jeff Bagwell (TRISTAR)) except for two I have gotten from going to a game and asking for autos from the players before games or afterwards.
    I have actually recieved some cards back from the mail, my two big prized ones are the Brett Favre RC and Don Mattingly RC autos. Super excited about those, and I didnt have to pay a company for them.

  9. chrisolds 1 September, 2012 at 18:26

    Alex: I have considered it. Problem is that I wouldn’t want to publish home addresses — and, depending on your focus, those can be the most-successful.

Leave a reply

We use cookies to help personalize content, tailor and measure ads, and provide a safer experience. By navigating the site, you agree to the use of cookies to collect information. Read our Cookie Policy.
Accept & Close