5 Key Madison Bumgarner Cards


Coming as a surprise to no one, Madison Bumgarner culminated his outstanding 2014 postseason in fitting fashion – by collecting the 2014 World Series MVP trophy. Bumgarner finished the postseason with 4-1 record with 45 strikeouts and a 1.03 ERA. In the World Series, he was 2-0 with 0.43 ERA and a save in the Series clinching seventh game.


Bumgarner cards have been smoking hot for the last several weeks, as collectors have been clamoring to add some Bumgarner cardboard to their collections. But with nearly 1,500 cards in the Beckett Online Price Guide,  sifting through the secondary market looking for Bumgarner gold can be a daunting task.

Below, you’ll find five key Madison Bumgarner cards. Some are autographed, some are not. Some are expensive, some are inexpensive. All are worthy of a spot in your collection.

October 30 - Bumgarner AFLAC

2006 Topps AFLAC Autographs Madison Bumgarner #MB

Released when he was still in high school, the 2006 Topps AFLAC ($80) card is Bumgarner’s first. In 2008 Bowman Draft, Topps released this certified autographed version. Though not serial numbered, the 2006 Topps AFLAC Autographs were tough pulls, falling one in every 215 hobby packs. A $50 card just weeks ago, it has skyrocketed to $150 following the World Series.


October 30 - Bumgarner 07 Bowman Chrome

2007 Bowman Chrome Draft Draft Picks Madison Bumgarner #BDPP61

An affordable option for collectors, Bumgarner’s first professional cards were released in the 2007 Bowman/Bowman Chrome Draft product. Though not a “true” Rookie Card, it has still been popular with collectors, doubling in value over the last several weeks.


October 30 - Bumgarner EEE

2007 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Madison Bumgarner #117

A week after the 2007 Bowman Chrome Draft product was released, Donruss Elite Extra Edition hit hobby store shelves and featured Bumgarner’s first certified autograph cards. Limited to 794 copies, it debuted in the Price Guide at $30. A $50 card entering the postseason, it is now selling on the secondary market in the $40-$80 range.


October 30 - Bumgarner Sterling

2007 Bowman Sterling Prospects Madison Bumgarner #MBB

Bumgarner’s first Bowman certified autograph, this card is plentiful on the secondary market. Still, demand is outweighing supply, as the card has doubled in value over the last two weeks. As to be expected BGS 9.5 copies are selling for a slight premium, though it does look to be an easy 9.5. Of the 286 copies that BGS has graded, an astounding 243 have been deemed worthy of the Gem Mt label, with 25 receiving the prestigious Pristine grade.



October 30 - Bumgarner 08 Bowman Chrome

2008 Bowman Chrome Prospects Madison Bumgarner #BCP120

Bumgarner’s hottest (and most volatile) card has been his 2008 Bowman Chrome Prospects autograph. Utilizing the same photo as his 2007 Bowman Chrome Prospects card, this card also features a certified autograph. A $25 card when it debuted in the Price Guide, it was selling in the $30-$80 range just weeks ago. The few sales that have occurred since the World Series ended have been all over the map, so it may be best to wait a few days – or even weeks – to let the dust settle a bit before trying to add this card to your collection.



Brian Fleischer

A collector since 1986, Brian has spent the last 15 years working as an Analyst in the Beckett pricing department. A vintage baseball card collector, he also collects vintage European soccer cards and pre-war Fordham University sports memorabilia. Have a question? You can reach him by email.

Tens of millions of cards available for sale in the
Beckett Marketplace!

Get up-to-date pricing for your favorite sports cards with a
Beckett OPG Subscription


  1. mathew 31 October, 2014 at 14:48

    I find it quite humorous that none of these are his “official,” MLB-sanctioned rookie cards. Just goes to show just how silly and inconsequential that MLB Rookie logo really is.

Leave a reply

We use cookies to help personalize content, tailor and measure ads, and provide a safer experience. By navigating the site, you agree to the use of cookies to collect information. Read our Cookie Policy.
Accept & Close