Connor McDavid Rookie Card Countdown

31
Share:

The hype is real with Connor McDavid Rookie Cards. He burst into the NHL with lofty expectations that were further fuelled by comparisons to another member of the Edmonton Oilers, Wayne Gretzky. Others have had that label with varying results. Still, Connor McDavid seems different. It’s still early in his career but mentions of Gretzky and Sidney Crosby don’t seem too far-fetched. They might even be fair.

Connor-McDavid-Rookie-Cards-Header

Upper Deck recognized this, signing McDavid to an exclusive deal. They proceeded to make him a focal point of a deep 2015-16 rookie crop. Even an extended injury didn’t derail things much as Connor McDavid Rookie Cards took on the same phenom status as the player.

What are the best and most valuable Connor McDavid Rookie Cards? We’ve ranked them all.

Most Valuable Connor McDavid Rookie Cards

Rankings for the following list are based prices in the Beckett Hockey Card Price Guide and Database. Only cards with the RC designation are included, not inserts and parallels.

20. 2015-16 Upper Deck Portfolio Connor McDavid RC #250

While not all Connor McDavid Rookie Cards have autographs or extremely low print runs, most have some sort of characteristic that takes them outside of a plain base card. This one’s the exception. It’s not a short print. It has no gimmicks other than being the cheapest of the superstar’s Rookies.

Parallels: Autographs

Buy on:

2015-16 Upper Deck Portfolio Connor McDavid Rookie Card

19. 2015-16 Upper Deck Overtime Connor McDavid RC #180

2015-16 Upper Deck Overtime wasn’t offered by regular means. That said, it was still widely available in hockey circles. Overtime packs were given to dealers as an order incentive with select distributors. Most then passed them on to their customers. The product was spread over three waves with McDavid closing out the base set checklist of the final wave.

Parallels: Autographs, Blue, Red (/99)

Buy on:


18. 2015-16 Upper Deck Champ’s Connor McDavid RC #315 SP

The 2015-16 Upper Deck Champ’s Connor McDavid Rookie Card brings an old-time feel with it, similar to Allen & Ginter in baseball. Part of the High Series Short Prints subset, it’s a moderately tough pull. The pool has 45 cards with one landing every five packs.

Parallels: Autographs, Gold Variant Back, Gold Variant Front, Silver (/25)

Buy on:


17. 2015-16 Upper Deck Trilogy Connor McDavid RC #101 /999

This foil-based card is one of many Connor McDavid Rookie Cards to come serial numbered. At 999 copies, it’s not exactly rare by today’s standards but it still makes it more appealing to some than it might otherwise be. Much of the attention Trilogy gets is for its autographs. As a result, it could be argued the base cards are a little overlooked.

Parallels: Rainbow Green (/599), Rainbow Blue (/399) ,Rainbow Black (/49)

Buy on:

2015-16 Upper Deck Trilogy Connor McDavid RC

16. 2015-16 Upper Deck Full Force Connor McDavid RC #101

2015-16 Upper Deck Full Force is a product that revels in bolder designs. While much of that is portrayed in the inserts, it’s also in the Rookie Cards. All are done with a 3-D effect using lenticular technology. It’s clear and quite sharp compared to old-school lenticular images from the 1980s and ’90s.

Rookies are also short prints in the product, falling one per box.

Parallels: Die Cuts

Buy on:


15. 2015-16 Artifacts Connor McDavid RC #205 /899

For those busting packs of 2015-16 Artifacts Hockey, if you were hoping for McDavid, you were looking for the Edmonton Oilers Rookie Redemption card. Because of the set’s early release, Upper Deck goes with mystery redemptions to work more rookie content into the product. Although numbered to 899 copies, redemptions don’t always result in all of those surfacing so it’s possible down the road that this one could be a little tougher to find than the print run suggests.

Parallels: Rookie Jersey Autographs, Jersey Patch Emerald (/199), Rookie Jersey Autographs Spectrum (/99), Rookie Jersey Emerald (/49)

Buy on:


14. 2015-16 Exquisite Collection Connor McDavid RC #R30 /299

2015-16 Exquisite Collection wasn’t released on its own. Rather, packs came with select high-end products including Black Diamond and The Cup. This particular Connor McDavid Rookie Card was released alongside 2015-16 Upper Deck Ice. Sticking with Exquisite’s history in all sports, the look emphasizes elegance. However, the print run and lack of autographs or patches (they’re available on other Exquisite inserts) keep the price of this one relatively in line.

Parallels: Gold Spectrum (/97), Black (1/1)

Buy on:

2015-16 Exquisite Connor McDavid RC

13. 2015-16 Upper Deck Connor McDavid RC #201

It may not be the most valuable Connor McDavid Rookie Card but his Young Guns release is probably his most collected. If you’re familiar with modern hockey cards, you know the drill. Flagship Upper Deck has been wildly popular with set collectors since its earliest days. When Young Guns became moderate short prints, they not only held their value but expanded their reach.

Knowing McDavid’s popularity would reach phenom status early on, it appears as though Upper Deck printed more of 2015-16 Upper Deck Series 1 than usual for the annual release. Supply and demand has ensured that this still didn’t matter too much as there are many who don’t normally collect hockey cards who chased the Connor McDavid Young Guns card down.

Parallels: Acetate, Foil, Exclusives (/100), High Gloss (/10), Printing Plates Black (1/1), Printing Plates Cyan (1/1), Printing Plates Magenta (1/1), Printing Plates Yellow (1/1)

Buy on:

2015-16 Upper Deck Connor McDavid Rookie Card Young Guns

12. 2015-16 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Connor McDavid RC #190 Autograph

If you want a Connor McDavid Rookie Card that’s signed, 2015-16 O-Pee-Chee Platinum offers some of the best value. It might not be the most valuable but it does come with an on-card signature. Modeled largely after Topps Chrome, the card also has a lot of parallels that bring more colors and textures as well as rarities.

Parallels: Rainbow, Traxx (/125), White Ice (/99), Red Prism (/75), Black Ice (/50), Blue Cubes (/35), Seismic Gold (/25), Rainbow Purple (/15), Emerald Surge (/10), Golden Treasures (1/1)

Buy on:

2015-16 O-Pee-Chee Platinum Connor McDavid RC Autograph

11. 2015-16 Upper Deck Contours Connor McDavid RC #131 Auto Jersey /199

2015-16 Upper Deck Contours rests somewhere in the realm between the company’s flagship release and the more wildly inclinded Full Force. Even when designs in the product take a more subtle approach, something is often added to make it stand out. So when you hear about McDavid’s card in the set, you jump to a somewhat standard autographed jersey image. And it is, but the card is also die-cut.

Numbered to 199 copies it’s pretty rare. And with only one parallel, it isn’t watered down with so many different versions of essentially the same card. The signature comes on-card and the swatch is fairly large, which are also pros for the card.

Parallels: Rookie Patch Autographs (/15)

Buy on:


10. 2015-16 Fleer Showcase Connor McDavid RC #189 Auto Patch /299

Fleer Showcase has entrenched itself as Upper Deck’s modern retro hockey brand. While much of the content relies on updated versions of classic sets and inserts, Rookie Cards are more about the content. Sure, the name is a throwback, but it’s one that doesn’t have a lot of power from the past. Rather, it’s the fact that key players have both autographs and patches on their cards.

With a significantly higher print run than The Cup and UD Premier (at least when it comes to low numbered cards) and not quite the same premium levels (ie smaller patch, sticker autograph), this one’s a lot cheaper than McDavid’s comparable cards.

Parallels: Red Golw (/25), White Hot (/5)

Buy on:


9. 2015-16 SPx Connor McDavid RC #169 Auto Jersey /399

2015-16 SPx changed things up a bit. The design is still busy, one of the brand’s trademarks. But Upper Deck brought even more. For starters, rookies went from have one over-sized swatch to four smaller ones. Also, acetate was added as a design element for the player’s photo. It’s a look that will appeal to some and keep others away. Still, the brand has a lot of history so the somewhat higher print run compared to similar brands doesn’t matter quite so much.

Parallels: Red (/50), Green (/10)

Buy on:

2015-16 SPx Connor McDavid RC

8. 2015-16 SP Authentic Connor McDavid RC #226 Autograph /999

Speaking of print runs being less important than brand popularity, take a look at the 2015-16 SP Authentic Connor McDavid Rookie Card. Despite having one short of 1,000 copies, it’s one of his most valuable cards. Why? History. SP Authentic is kind of like the set builder’s product for the more high-end crowd. It’s similar in that regard to Contenders Football.

The Future Watch name carries a lot of clout with hockey card collectors. The tradition of on-card signatures certainly helps, too.

Parallels: Limited Patch Autographs (/100)

Buy on:

2015-16 SP Authentic Connor McDavid Rookie Card Autograph

7. 2015-16 UD Black Connor McDavid RC #85 Autograph /199

Mixing elegance and a boldness, the 2015-16 UD Black Connor McDavid Rookie Card stands out automatically due to its dark design. Not only that, but the signature comes in silver adding further contrast. Some of the value for the card comes from the fact that UD Black wasn’t cheap to begin with. The brand is recognized as one of Upper Deck’s top, although not quite to the same level as The Cup.

Parallels: Gold Spectrum (/25)

Buy on:

2015-16 UD Black Connor McDavid RC

6. 2015-16 Upper Deck Premier Connor McDavid RC #115 Auto Patch /199

Let’s be honest. With so many options of mixing autographs and patches on a Rookie Card, it can be hard to make something really stand out. UD Premier manages to do that in a way that’s somewhat subtle. Likely inspired by 2013-14 Panini National Treasures, the cards forego traditional card stock and go with acetate instead. The result is something different but not too different. The patch window on McDavid’s card is also quite large.

Parallels: Silver Spectrum (/35), Gold Spectrum (/10), Blue Spectrum (1/1)

Buy on:

2015-16 Upper Deck Premier Connor McDavid RC

5. 2015-16 Ultimate Collection Connor McDavid RC #109 Autograph /99

One of a handful of McDavid Rookies numbered to less than 100, the base version of Ultimate Collection also comes autographed. The print run and the signature are the main drivers behind the card’s high value. Although it has several parallels, not all of them are signed. In fact, the Silver Jersey card is one of those strange instances where the parallel is more plentiful than the original.

Parallels (* notes parallels that are NOT autographed): Silver Jersey* (/149), Spectrum Silver Jersey Autograph (/49), Gold Patch* (/25), Spectrum Gold Patch Autograph (/10), Platinum Blue Tag* (/5), Spectrum Teal Autograph Shield (1/1)

Buy on:

2015-16 Ultimate Collection Connor McDavid RC

4. 2015-16 SP Game Used Connor McDavid RC #197 /97

For a couple of years, SP Game Used has been limiting Rookie Cards to the player’s jersey number. So even with the 97 on his back, this is the rarest Connor McDavid Rookie Card. That’s the big reason why it ranks so high when it comes to price point. The overall design doesn’t necessarily reflect the same sort of high-end design.

Parallels: Autographs Blue, Copper Jersey (/399), Spectrum Materials (/99), Autographs (1/1)

Buy on:

2015-16 SP Game Used Connor McDavid Rookie Card

3. 2015-16 Black Diamond Connor McDavid RC #BDRCM /99

Of all the hockey brands to get an overhaul in 2015-16, Black Diamond was probably the biggest. It went from a mid-range product to a premium configuration. For Rookies, the brand name took on a more literal interpretation with the addition of actual diamonds to the cards. Combine that with a print run of 99 copies and you’re near the top of the Connor McDavid Rookie Card mountain.

Parallels: Gold Diamond (/5), Pure Black Diamond (1/1)

Buy on:

2015-16 Black Diamond Connor McDavid RC

2. 2015-16 Upper Deck Ice Connor McDavid RC #200 /99

Card collecting can be funny sometimes. Usually we look to autographs to bring the biggest values. While they certainly enhance the Connor McDavid Rookie Card portfolio, it’s not the lone requirement. His Upper Deck Ice card is a massive exception. It has no signature, no relic and it’s not his rarest card (although it is only two copies off). What it does have is a brand history and an acetate design that’s distinct.

Buy on:

2015-16 Upper Deck Ice Connor McDavid Rookie Card

1. 2015-16 Upper Deck The Cup Connor McDavid RC #197 /99

And here it is, the big one, the most valuable one of all, the 2015-16 Upper Deck The Cup Connor McDavid Rookie Card. Autograph, patch, tiny print run, high-profile release, brand affinity — the card literally has it all. Even though it arrived on the late side, that didn’t stop it from arriving with plenty of hype and high price tags.

Part of the reason why people are chasing this card is the prestige. There are several other cards that come with similar features and print runs that go for a fraction of what the actual The Cup Connor McDavid goes for.

For those chasing the best Connor McDavid Rookie Card, the search ends here.

Buy on:

2015-16 Upper Deck The Cup Connor McDavid Rookie Card

Share:

Ryan Cracknell

A collector for much of his life, Ryan focuses primarily on building sets, Montreal Expos and interesting cards. He's also got one of the most comprehensive collections of John Jaha cards in existence (not that there are a lot of them). Got a question, story idea or want to get in touch? You can reach him by email and through Twitter @tradercracks.

Tens of millions of cards available for sale in the
Beckett Marketplace!

Get up-to-date pricing for your favorite sports cards with a
Beckett OPG Subscription

31 comments

  1. Lee 10 February, 2017 at 12:07

    Hey, I’m lookin to get an approximate value in a card. It’s a Connor Mcdavid Trilogy level 2 autographed card #91/499

    Thanks!

    Lee

  2. John Mallory 21 February, 2017 at 01:30

    What Is Mcdavid’a absolute rarest True Rookie card? I am thinking it may be his 15/16 #97/97 SP Game Used because it comes from the shortest True Rookie print run and is the only card in the series to carry his signature…(an “auto variation” card). I would think the combination of these two rare attributes would make this particular card one of his most collectible cards would it not?

  3. Aaron 23 May, 2017 at 16:03

    Is the 97/97 SP Game Used also considered to be the 1/1 referred to in the article? If so then it would be a 1/1 True Rookie would it not? Add in the fact that A) SP Game Used is ranked #3 of all True Rookie cards, B) the 97/97 is the only one of the 97 to be autographed and come with a COA, C) the 97/97 is a jersey number card, D) SP Game Used is the rarest True Rookie run of them all and E) this particular card might be considered to be a “1/1 True Rookie”…and you have one amazing card! I see the 1/1 just graded a BGS 9.5 !! WOW,…the 97/97 SP Game Used card may be THE GRETZKY CARD of our modern era…pretty much priceless in my mind!

  4. Steve Z. 3 June, 2017 at 17:23

    Yes, agreed. 97/97 SP Game Used would be McDavid’s rarest true Rookie. Although technically not a 1 of 1, it strangely appears to be designated a 1 of 1 card. Whatever it is, it is likely his most collectible card because of all it has going for it – even without a patch!

    • Ryan Cracknell 5 June, 2017 at 11:38

      Sure the 97/97 may be more desirable to some, but it’s a 1/1 in the same way 1/97, 96/97 and 14/97 are. Would it command a premium? Sure. One-of-one? In the same way that the other 96 copies are.

  5. Steve Z. 5 June, 2017 at 16:13

    The 15/16 SP Game Used 97/97 (his rookie) is unique because is the only one to carry McDavid’s autograph & come with a certificate of authentication. The product markets the 97/97 as an “Auto Variation 1 of 1” so it would likely command a steep premium. The 16/17 SP Game Used 97/97 (not his Rookie) recently sold for $1027 whereas the other 96 are currently selling for between $11 and $50.

  6. mike 9 July, 2017 at 19:54

    the 15/16 sp game used 97/97 is the only one autod but its a sticker and not hard signed. still a crazy pull it doesn’t even have his number in the auto which means an older version of the autograph.

    MY OPTION ONLY:
    MY TOP 6 ( CONSIDER SALES ON EBAY )
    1.THE CUP
    2. UPPER DECK ICE
    3.SPA
    4.BLACK DIAMOND
    5.ULTIMATE
    6.UPPER DECK PREMIER

  7. Rob Olson 31 October, 2017 at 01:29

    What about UD high gloss young guns and exclusives. I would say the highest graded high gloss will end up being the most valuable card ever made.

    • Ryan Cracknell 31 October, 2017 at 09:57

      @Rob – They are popular and great cards. This article is focused only on RC cards, which is noted at the top of the list, not parallels.

  8. Albert 5 March, 2018 at 13:20

    I have 2015-16 SP AUTHENTIC CONNOR MCDAVID RC #226 AUTOGRAPH but it is Black and is supposedly 1 of 5.

    Do you have any details?
    Thanks,
    Albert

  9. Ken 16 October, 2018 at 21:46

    Any idea on what it would take to acquire the entire set of the “2015-16 Upper Deck The Cup Connor McDavid #Cup-197 Rookie Auto Patch Masterpieces” consisting of all four printing plates, i.e., Black, Cyan, Magenta, and Yellow? I don’t believe that they are even listed on Beckett.

    • Ryan Cracknell 17 October, 2018 at 12:28

      @Ken – Unfortunately very difficult to say on several levels. First, they need to be tracked down. Then, being 1/1s it’s about the person with them naming their price. It could vary greatly.

  10. Ken 18 October, 2018 at 22:25

    Appreciate your prompt response, Ryan. Hypothetically speaking, would you trade a marginally-low-grade (e.g., BGS 8.5) “2015-16 Upper Deck The Cup Connor McDavid #197 Rookie Auto Patch” /99 Rookie Card plus $5,000 for the entire set (Black, Cyan, Magenta, and Yellow) of the “2015-16 Upper Deck The Cup Connor McDavid #Cup-197 Rookie Auto Patch Masterpieces” in the highly-unlikely event that someone were able to beat the near-impossible odds of assembling all four printing plates simultaneously in the future?

    • Ryan Cracknell 19 October, 2018 at 10:36

      @Ken – For my own personal collecting tastes, I’d rather have one RC over all four of the 1/1 Printing Plates. But that’s because my collection focuses on Rookie Cards. And, I’m not personally a big fan of how Printing Plates look so I don’t chase them. I could definitely see other people thinking the opposite.

  11. Albert Rehanek 9 September, 2019 at 14:36

    I have 2015-16 SP AUTHENTIC CONNOR MCDAVID RC #226 AUTOGRAPH but it is All Black and is supposedly 1 of 5.

    Do you have any details?
    Thanks,
    Albert

  12. Jason Clifford 14 May, 2020 at 03:06

    Hi! Time to update the list.
    YG buybacks /97 Blue and /25 Gold are missing

  13. Tim 29 July, 2020 at 18:58

    Are you kidding me? Top 20 McDavid rookies and the 15-16 SP Future Watch Auto Patch #’d to 100 doesn’t make the list? Not to mention the retro patch auto #’d to 25? Man. How do either of these not even crack the top 20? The first one BOOK listed at $2500 when it came out of the pack in 2015. I sold it for $1625 on the bay. And I think the Patches were absolutely beautiful multi color swatches that really made the card special.

    • Ryan Cracknell 31 July, 2020 at 11:13

      @Tim – It’s a parallel. The article mentions only base RC cards are listed. This one is highlighted with the SPA RC.

  14. Tim 29 July, 2020 at 19:03

    Albert. Those are what is known as “easter eggs” meaning, they were cards that were inserted but were not announced as part of the product set. Rate of insertion was also not officially released. I have the Dylan Larkin. I did some research and finally discovered the intent of these cards. Value for one of the McDavids is limitless due to its scarcity. ( i think thats how you spell that).

  15. Brent colbridgr 31 July, 2020 at 15:58

    Hi I have a 2015-16 o pee chee glossy rookies BLACK connor mcdavid #r-1 rookie card. Its book value is listed at $200 according to the latest paper version of Beckett price guide but I havent been able to find this card for sale online ANYWHERE not one FOR sale OR a recent sales history for one on ebay which leads me to believe this card is SUPER rare I cant think of another card of a superstar like mcdavid or ANYWHERE CLOSE to him for that matter has no trace of selling or being up for sale online except for a 1 of 1 that someone’s holding onto ofcourse…lol so my question IS is it unreasonable to think that my card might just sell for MORE then bv as SO MANY very rare or highly in demand cards of superstars tend to do now a days and Is there ANYWHERE else I can look for a previous sale of this card OTHER then ebay, comc or PwC because between the three of those sites I’ve been able to find a previous sales history for ANY other mcdavid rookie I’ve bothered to look up??? Thx

  16. Ron Palmer 2 January, 2021 at 01:16

    What about 2014 trilogy and itg heroes and prospects. I have one of each. Those were some of the rarest trilogy I have out of 9 and heroes I have out of 50.

  17. OhLHiver 12 January, 2021 at 09:19

    Hi guys, I have a question for all of you. Is this card special?
    Sports Illustrated for Kids #282 – Connor McDavid Auto/Signed – Framed in some “glass” and hermetically sealed by Topps Finest? ?

  18. Timmy 15 January, 2021 at 15:04

    I know this article isn’t about parallels but I put the OPC Platinum Rookie Auto Golden Treasures as the most valuable Connor Mcdavid card on the planet. It’s not just a 1 of 1, it is the 1/1 “top of the mountain”, “holy grail” card in a large pyramid series of Auto rookies. And in my opinion the nicest set of Parallel Rookie Autos.

  19. Jody Gillis 8 April, 2021 at 17:26

    Saw a 2015 RC Connor mcdavid platinum retro gem graded 9 by PSA FOR 1000. I cannot find info on this card. Does anyone know anything?

Leave a reply

We use cookies to help personalize content, tailor and measure ads, and provide a safer experience. By navigating the site, you agree to the use of cookies to collect information. Read our Cookie Policy.
Accept & Close