[coltsfansince85]

Well, obviously I was pretty psyched to land my first Edgerrin shield! However, when it arrived I was less than enthused. I'm having a hard time remaining objective, so hope I can get some reliable info here.

Now, I was out of the hobby when this set was released... but a couple of things jump out at me:

1- aren't shields usually reserved for 1/1s, what's this doing in a card #d /19?
2- I don't think I've ever seen a shield upside down
3- there is a crease in the upper left, and the right side of the window is clearly peeling away from the card stock.

[ft28jags]

Gonna go with yes

[melcmd]

I'd say it was faked. The side of the window is severely damaged from either removing the original patch, putting in the new patch or a combination of the 2.

[coltsfansince85]

Yeah, I've already started the return process. Plain as day in person, but on my phone it looked pretty good.

Thanks for the feedback.

[rwgreen]

yup....as fake as they come

[soccerscrub]

I'm having the same issue with a Peyton Manning that I want to purchase, I'm pretty sure the patch in it is fake and unfortunately, I will not be buying it...

[coltsfansince85]

I was lucky enough to have encountered what appears to be a good seller. Apparently, what had happened was... he got back into collecting because he's a Mariota fan. This was his buddy's card, he was selling it on his behalf and hadn't realized it was counterfeit. Refunded in full and asked that I not ship the card back- told him I'd destroy it, note there were only 18 (or less) remaining.

[jonathani]

In my experience Leaf does not make these kinds of mistakes, only Topps.

[j7r7o7c7k7]

I was lucky enough to have encountered what appears to be a good seller. Apparently, what had happened was... he got back into collecting because he's a Mariota fan. This was his buddy's card, he was selling it on his behalf and hadn't realized it was counterfeit. Refunded in full and asked that I not ship the card back- told him I'd destroy it, note there were only 18 (or less) remaining.

Few things. The patch is in fact fake. I own the 1/1 shield mirror black of this card. I also own 2-3 of this card /19 mirror gold and none have any part of the laundry tag. Please DO NOT destroy this card. I would love to have it for my collection. Though the patch might be fake, it still is a nice card /19. If you don't want it I would be happy to own it. It would never be sold. Let me know? Thanks

Also if you ever want to know some info about Edgerrin cards I know a lot about them and own many of them and the ones I don't own there is a good chance I have seen. I 9 out of 10 times can see a card of his a know if its a fake before I ever click on the auction (seen this one on ebay). Patches, autos, etc. I would be glad to offer advice, as long as you let me win a few I need! lol