[coltsfansince85]

I guess I'm a novice when it comes to grades... but that seems like a pretty awesome submission! Would it worth cracking them and sending to PSA to see if they get 9.5-10?

[pudge27t]

I guess I'm a novice when it comes to grades... but that seems like a pretty awesome submission! Would it worth cracking them and sending to PSA to see if they get 9.5-10?

Well I do agree with the statement earlier of BGS being tougher, which is one of the main reasons I went this route, plus I like the casings better!

I just meant, a couple I knew were a 9 and others I thought at least a 9.5, but oh well! When looking at the POP on these, most are 1/1's anyways!

These 3 I just "knew" were a 9.5, or so I thought.
2006 Ultimate Collection Gold AU/10 9/10
2006 SP Authentic Gold JSY AU/25 9/10
2006 SP Authentic JSY/299 AU 9/10


These I hoped were a 9 & they made the cut!
2006 Topps Heritage Gridiron Collection Jersey Autographs/25 9/10
2006 Upper Deck Rookie Debut AU/25* RC 9/10


The rest I had no idea since they were thicker cards but in my experience most sharp looking exquisite cards grade a 9.


OT: My most prized Reggie Bush RC AUTO 1/1 got a 9 & I just don't see what they see YET i'm not a "pro" and it is a 1/1.. POP 1 at that.

[fast93bird]

I've found that it's VERY hard to snag a 9.5 or better on a jersey card. I've broken out a couple of PSA 10's and micro scrutininzed them, couldn't find any flaws, and still come back with a 9. It's frustrating considering if you don't see what they saw, you have no idea what they saw that caused the markdown. Part of the game.

[pudge27t]

I've found that it's VERY hard to snag a 9.5 or better on a jersey card. I've broken out a couple of PSA 10's and micro scrutininzed them, couldn't find any flaws, and still come back with a 9. It's frustrating considering if you don't see what they saw, you have no idea what they saw that caused the markdown. Part of the game.

Painfully agreed!