[monsterx]

Like the title says, should I keep and hope for the Rodgers effect, or trade now? Don't know much about him...

Card in question is a Contenders auto.

Thanks

[kstjst]

I seem to pull a lot of Osweiler's and I fight with myself over this very same question. On one hand, you know that Peyton only has a few years left, so he is probably coming in at the right time to learn and then take over. But no one will ever know until we see him play.

I've had Triple Threads, Prizm, Contenders, and now a Supreme limited to 5...I've sold all but the Supreme, which is currently up for sale on the premise that I can always get his cards back next season when the hype of his rookie year is done. He sells pretty decent now for a guy that hasn't done much, but I guarantee that unless he's thrust into an emergency starting role next season, prices will go down. So get what you can now.

[sevans1979]

I say keep it. He could pull a Kaepernick one day

[DesertFox24]

Keep it, Manning could get injured at his advanced age and I get the feeling he can do some good things

[jeremy7269]

Like the title says, should I keep and hope for the Rodgers effect, or trade now? Don't know much about him...

Card in question is a Contenders auto.

Thanks

I think getting a few Osweiler's is a wise investment. I would trade, sell, or grade the contenders auto though. You want to have a couple of his cards that are unique and high end. That way if he does get the Rodgers virus, you will have cards that do not look like everyone elses.

[jfrench91]

i have 9 of his auto's and im going to keep them.. anymore unless someone else wants them for their collections ill keep ANY qb auto card and put it away. im not one to sell alotve cards but as someone says.. if he pulls a kaepernick on everyone then i may pull the trigger,but other than that.. hes got a neat autograph haha

[monsterx]

Haha, split jury so far! I see what you're saying there Sevans and DesertFox, Manning's old and on his way out the door...

[sevans1979]

Haha, split jury so far! I see what you're saying there Sevans and DesertFox, Manning's old and on his way out the door...

Yeah man I traded a Wilson auto and a Colin /5 jumbo patch then they both went off. I'm just going to hoard everything I pull and hope someone I have takes off lol

[monsterx]

Yeah man I traded a Wilson auto and a Colin /5 jumbo patch then they both went off. I'm just going to hoard everything I pull and hope someone I have takes off lol

Yeah dude...pulled a Kaep Contenders about 2 weeks before Smith went down. Hence the thread lol.. Wanted to know what everyone thinks about Osweiler.

[pudge27t]

I'd hold onto at least one of his autos! lol U never know! He might learn someting!