[aktlingit]

Drop:
Adam Wainwright
Josh Reddick
Jason Motte
Lance Lynn
Jon Jay
Salvador Perez
Victor Martinez
Edwin Encarnacion
Ben Revere
Alex Avila
Jeremey Hellickson
Tim Hudson
Carl Crawford
Yovani Gallardo
Aramis Ramirez

Add:
Brett Lawrie
Manny Machado
Jake Peavey
Chris Sale
Todd Helton

[renfrow831]

I would drop...
Freese
CJ Wilson
Napoli
Shin Soo Choo
Encarnacion
Buchholz
Morse
Avila
Nelson Cruz
Parker
Jay
Hanaran
Revere
Lester
Motte


I would add...
Lawrie
Profar
Middlebrooks
Cespedes
Machado

Just my opinion help it helps.

[daddys lil all star]

Drop:
Melky Cabrera
Clay Buccholz
Lance Lynn
Brandon Belt
Jon Jay
Joel Hanrahan
Shin Soo Choo
Michael Pineda
Nelson Cruz
Edwin Encarnacion
Mike Morse
B.J. Upton
Jason Motte
Hunter Pence
Salvador Perez

Add:
Yoenis Cespedes
Brett Lawrie
Hank Aaron
Manny Machado
Chipper Jones

[Haze28]

PLAYER LIST:
Adrian Gonzalez
Mark Teixeira
Melky Cabrera
Shin Soo Choo
Austin Jackson
Edwin Encarnacion
Ben Revere
Alex Avila
Lance Lynn
Jon Jay
Salvador Perez
Aramis Ramirez
Joel Hanrahan
David Freese
Mike Napoli


Those are the first 15 I would axe. I'll have to look deeper later when I have time lol.

You should add

Brett Lawrie
James Shields
Ryan Dempster
Anthony Rizzo
Paul Goldschmidt

[jrod7290]

Drop:
Jarrod Parker
Yovanni Gallardo
Asdrubal Cabrera
Tim Hudson
Billy Butler
Josh Johnson
C.J. Wilson
Melky Cabrera
Victor Martinez
Kevin Youkilis
Mike Napoli
Clay Buchholz
Ben Revere
Jordan Zimmerman
Michael Pineda

Add:
Jim Thome
Will Middlebrooks
Manny Machado
Brett Lawrie
Anthony Rizzo

[brian2345]

Drop
L.Lynn
T.Hudson
J.Jay
R.A. Dickey
J.Hanrahan
Melkey Cabrera
J.Motte
C.J.Wilson
J.Reddick
C.Buchholtz
A.Dunn
M.Morse
B.Revere
B.J.Upton
M.Pineda

Add
M.Machado
I.Davis
N.Swisher
D.Jennings
M.Latos

[Blury1]

Mike Napoli
Cj Wilson
Sin soo choo
Cliff lee
Michael Pineda
Lance Lynn
Mike morse
Salvador Perez
Tori hunter
Jon jay
Dan uggla
David freeze
Jacoby ellsbury
Ben revere
Bj upton




Brett lawerie
Yoenis cespedes
Manny machado
Jose altuve
Elvis andrus

[acevanquish]

Add: MORE BASS!!

[rjcj2017]

Great question, thanks for the contest!

OFF THE LIST AND WHY:

Greinke — doesn't move the needle much, changed teams three times in two years
Melk Cabrera — All the Roidsters are automatically off
Youkilis — Best days are behind him and they weren't that great
Jordan Zimmermann — Not even best Zimmerman(n) on his own team
Jason Motte — Closers are temporary and replaceable
Mike Morse — Roids (with Seattle)
Johnny Cueto — Never trust guys who only sign their first name
Alex ROIDriguez — Uh, roids
Joel Hanrahan — See Motte, Jason
Mike Napoli — See Youkilis, Kevin
Ben Revere — Limited overall skills, and plays for the Twins
Allen Craig — There are like six position players and four pitchers on the Cardinals that are really just the same guy
Jon Jay — There are like six position players and four pitchers on the Cardinals that are really just the same guy
Lance Lynn — There are like six position players and four pitchers on the Cardinals that are really just the same guy
Adam Wainright — There are like six position players and four pitchers on the Cardinals that are really just the same guy

ADD THESE GUYS LIKE YESTERDAY AND WHY:

Yoenis Cespedes — Will be an All-Star if he stays healthy
Brett Lawrie — Good hitter, so far no roids
Will Middlebrooks — See Lawrie, Brett
Jesus Montero — See Middlebrooks, Will
Chris Carter — No one knows who this guy is, major power potential for A's this year

Good luck to me and all the fellow contestants!

[DrMitchJ]

I would get rid of the following 15 from your list

PLAYER LIST:

Victor Martinez
Adrian Beltre
Johan Santana
Jon Lester
Mike Napoli
Shin Soo Choo
Edwin Encarnacion
Allen Craig
Carlos Gonzalez
Alex Avila
Lance Lynn
Nelson Cruz
Carl Crawford
Asdrubal Cabrera
David Freese



And I would add the following 5:

Starling Marte
Gary Sanchez
Anthony Rizzo
J. P. Arencibia
And one of my recent favorites ... Ubaldo Jimenez!

Thanks for the contest ... It's fun to think this stuff through