[jboedicker]

Torrey Smith lol

+1 lol, but for real Newton unless Dalton goes far into the playoffs like Gonzo said

[falcons2fan]

patrick peterson

[ricky williams 34]

If Dalton gets to the playoffs and is competitive, he gets it. Otherwise, it's Newton.

What he said.

[jdetter23]

100 % Newton.The difference between this team and last years team is night and day. Carolina scored like 16 total TD's last year. This year Newton has contributed to 16 TD's at the halfway point. Yea Dalton gets the wins but he has a defense. Look at how Carolina has been in EVERY game until the very end with Newton and Carolina has no defense. If we did we'd be looking at 1-2 more wins minimum to this point.

[wavytiger1975]

I honestly had no idea playoffs or how far into them you got mattered one bit. I guess with so many saying so that I must be wrong.

There was a preseason pick thread made and Andy Dalton was my pick, although the rest of my picks were probably way off.

and I found that thread
http://www.beckett.com/forums/thread-1455748.html

[Marinoisking]

I honestly had no idea playoffs or how far into them you got mattered one bit. I guess with so many saying so that I must be wrong.

There was a preseason pick thread made and Andy Dalton was my pick, although the rest of my picks were probably way off.

and I found that thread
http://www.beckett.com/forums/thread-1455748.html

hahahaha

I seen my picks
I think I might have a couple that COULD be right

I got Arian Foster as Offensive Player of the year
and Aldon Smith as the Defensive Rookie of the year....I guess both of those are still feasible

[ripkenfan72]

Dalton should get it!!!! He's getting the Ws and has his team at the top of his division when normally they are at the bottom.

Newton has the numbers but struggles to get the W.

The W is what its about in sports isn't it?

[cody_allen]

I'm sorry but Patrick petterson needs to start getting a little more respect, he's been a beast. His defense is going to get so much better, he will be a shut sown cb. Not to mention 3 returns for a td already! And two int. Cmon he's bad

[ripkenfan72]

I'm sorry but Patrick petterson needs to start getting a little more respect, he's been a beast. His defense is going to get so much better, he will be a shut sown cb. Not to mention 3 returns for a td already! And two int. Cmon he's bad

He did look tough the one time I saw him play

[koolkellygirl]

I think all the Cam haters need to take another look. Nobody hates Cam more than me, but, the guy is getting the stats-BIG time and he has broken a record or 2 along the way: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-09-12...ssing.html

Sorry people, Andy Dalton may prove himself down the line but right now he's an adequate qb with a good team-or he'd have the stats.

Stats are what counts, ask Marino...