[jkiddlridnour]

It takes one good year to separate them. If AP (I know, I hate ifs too) did not get back this year like they all thought, those numbers could have changed drastically. AP has been to the post season, what, once? let's see him play a few more years before saying he's a shoe-in, cause I don't think he is...

I don't agree with it either, I just think he's better than Rice. Those stats didn't include APs 1,300+ yard, 12 TD rookie season. But like I said, I think AP needs probably around 2+ more seasons of his normal stats to be considered.