I still find it hard to believe that Upper Deck would send out an MJ auto as a replacement for anything, much less a card that isn't from a basketball product; much less an MJ that is seven years older than your redemption; and the fact that it's not numbered is weird, too.
I mean, the Rivers/Roethlisberger is from 2005, you said, so that's not their rookie year. Even if it was /25, what is that, a $250-$300 card?
Still not worth the MJ ... I don't know what the MJ auto values were back then, but I would be shocked if it still wasn't a couple hundred more dollars (at least) than your redemption.
I mean, great for you, but ...