+- Beckett Message Boards (https://www.beckett.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Hobby Talk (https://www.beckett.com/forums/forum-1.html)
+--- Forum: Football (https://www.beckett.com/forums/forum-6.html)
+--- Thread: Asked Panini for replacements on redemptions (/thread-1500171.html)
Asked Panini for replacements on redemptions - georgehenrycollector - 05-18-2012
Here is what I am getting in return. Let me know what you guys think
#1. Had 2011 Panini Timeless Treasures NFL Rookies Signatures #131 /299
Aldon Smith San Francisco 49ers DE
Getting: 2011 Panini Gridiron Gear Signatures Gold #210 (275 / 299) T.J. Yates Houston Texans QB
#2. Had:
2011 Panini Timeless Treasures NFL Rookies Signatures #199 ( / 299)
Robert Housler Arizona Cardinals TE
Getting :
2011 Panini Gridiron Gear Signatures Gold #203 (124 / 299)
Ryan Kerrigan Washington Redskins LB
#3. Had:
2011 Panini Rookies and Stars SP Rookies Signatures #289 ( / 299) D.J. Williams Green Bay Packers TE
Getting:
2011 Panini Timeless Treasures NFL Rookies Signatures #205 (139 / 165) Ryan Williams Arizona Cardinals RB
RE: Asked Panini for replacements on redemptions - cheeseslices - 05-18-2012
I guess its a even swap, but I'd definitely rather have the Aldon than a Yates now
RE: Asked Panini for replacements on redemptions - cybertrenz02 - 05-18-2012
(05-18-2012, 01:22 PM)cheeseslices Wrote: I guess its a even swap, but I'd definitely rather have the Aldon than a Yates now
+1
RE: Asked Panini for replacements on redemptions - redskins316 - 05-18-2012
I'd say the same, they seem like even replacements, but Aldon Smith may only go up and Yates may only go down, but for now, I think they're good
RE: Asked Panini for replacements on redemptions - nthnoak - 05-18-2012
I too am waiting on a bunch of aldons including two of those timeless treasure ones. I will not be asking for replacements though as I want my aldons lol. A friend of mine had a prestige aldon redemption that got mailed out today so maybe aldon is signing now. Your replacements look okay except for the aldon one imo.
RE: Asked Panini for replacements on redemptions - totally sports - 05-18-2012
I think on the 2 you theres a good chance you went up a little but the Yates for Aldon Smith would be a little more risk imo. I am waiting on 2 from Panini also, they haven't replied to my email and I am dreading going further just from what I have read on threads on here. Am glad I traded the last 2 instead of redeeming them.