Yea, I just had this same thing happen to me just recently.
I collected all the 90's autographs and Fleer Highlights autographs with the stamping. I would send 1 - 3 with each grading order.
Here are all the ones they HAVE GRADED for me in the past (as recent as April):
6069336 Basketball 1992-93 Hoops J.Stockton Game AU 9.0 View
6069337 Football 1992 Pro Line Portraits Autographs Emmitt Smith 9.0 View
6243240 Baseball 1992 Fleer Clemens Roger Clemens AU/2000 8.0 View
6961104 Basketball 1993-94 Ultra Karl Malone Karl Malone AU 9.0 View
7153973 Basketball 1993-94 Hoops David Robinson 9.0 View
7153981 Hockey 1994-95 Ultra Sergei Fedorov Sergei Fedorov/AU 9.0 View
7153974 Basketball 1993-94 Fleer Clyde Drexler Clyde Drexler AU 9.0 View
7153980 Football 1992 Ultra Reggie White Autographs Reggie White 9.0 View
I just send 2 more and they rejected them both and sent me the same letter.
7407004 Baseball 1992 Ultra Gwynn Tony Gwynn AU 0.0 View
7407005 Hockey 1992-93 Ultra Jeremy Roenick Jeremy Roenick AU 0.0 View
What angers me even more is I sent a 1998 Elway/Davis Penpals Elway autograph and THAT WAS ALSO RECECTED. THEY GRADED THE WHOLE SET FOR ME BEFORE!!!! (The Manning/Leaf autograph I bought already graded)
6243257 Football 1998 Pinnacle Inscriptions Pen Pals J.Elway AU/T.Davis 9.5 View
6510573 Football 1998 Pinnacle Inscriptions Pen Pals B.Sanders/E.Smith 9.5 View
6510562 Football 1998 Pinnacle Inscriptions Pen Pals S.Mitchell AU/B.Sanders 9.0 View
6510563 Football 1998 Pinnacle Inscriptions Pen Pals R.Leaf/P.Manning No Auto 9.5 View
6510564 Football 1998 Pinnacle Inscriptions Pen Pals D.Bledsoe AU/K.Stewart AU 9.5 View
6510565 Football 1998 Pinnacle Inscriptions Pen Pals T.Aikman AU/K.Collins AU 9.5 View
6510566 Football 1998 Pinnacle Inscriptions Pen Pals Favre AU/B.Sanders No AU 9.5 View
6510568 Football 1998 Pinnacle Inscriptions Pen Pals Aikman AU/Irvin/Smith 7.5 View
6069329 Football 1998 Pinnacle Inscriptions Pen Pals J.Elway AU/B.Favre AU 9.5 View
6069330 Football 1998 Pinnacle Inscriptions Pen Pals J.Elway AU/D.Marino AU 9.5 View
6069331 Football 1998 Pinnacle Inscriptions Pen Pals J.Rice AU/S.Young AU 9.5 View
I emailed Charles (NY rep) about this and he gave me the "they never told me anything about rejecting those cards".
So needless to say I am also VERY UPSET about this.
If its a pack inserted autograph I cant understand the need the send to a third party authenticator to get graded. THE GRADERS ARE SUPPOSED TO KNOW THESE CARDS! THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO BE ABLE TO TELL THE FAKES! THATS WHAT WE ARE PAYING THEM FOR@!!!!!
To get cards graded at $30 a shot to ridiculous and they just may lose a customer in me if this is the new standard.
Im yet to contact Mark Anderson because Charles wants me to scan the remaining cards I have so he can forward and ask on my behalf if there will be any more issues. But I cant find my scanner plug.
Im getting fed up with Beckett's graders getting lazy and refusing to grade a card because they are uneducated on how to tell a fake one.