Beckett Message Boards

Anyone with experience and expertise with BGS grading care to share their personal opinion, estimation, approximation of what card could potentially grade ???
Thank you in advance! I appreciate your efforts and willingness to assist.
-Courey M

1998 Topps Stars Gold Luminaries #/50 Peyton Manning RC

8.5 maybe a 9 if you are lucky.

Thanks for your time and opinion! I know grading can be highly subjective and opinionated. I, too, had 8.5 in mind, but was curious as to what other member's viewed the card as. Appreciate the response.

I would estimate 7.5 or 8. Plus, how's the surface on both sides?

Nolan, appreciate the expertise! Surface is great on the front (no scratches, miscellaneous marks when tilted under the light). Kind of bummer about the back side. The front would easily great out to a 9 overall in my personal opinion.

(02-24-2012, 07:12 PM)coureymarshall Wrote: [ -> ]Nolan, appreciate the expertise! Surface is great on the front (no scratches, miscellaneous marks when tilted under the light). Kind of bummer about the back side. The front would easily great out to a 9 overall in my personal opinion.

Yeah, there's a lot of chipping on the edges and that corner.

Surface 9, Corners 8, Edges 7.5, Centering 9 overall probably an 8

AWESOME, appreciate the detailed insight. Thank you to everyone who was willing to lend a helping hand and assist me. GREATLY APPRECIATE each effort!