[shap6761]

what card would you rather have

1) Adrian Peterson Playoff Contenders RC Ticket Auto (BV = $600)

2) Marion Barber Exquisite RC Auto #/150 (BV = $450, and quickly rising)

[vgholston50]

AP.....no brainer. much better than barber IMO. just my $.02

[mlqb84]

AP. but thats only cuz im a huge vikings fan. so i am very biased. but marion barber is good

[supercardcollector]

Adrian Peterson
I love both guys
Peterson plays with my team in the Vikes
Barber played with my team in the Gophers
But I would have to say go with Peterson, better player IMO, and well I am a little biased since he is a Vike :lol:

[Barry Sanders=G.O.A.T]

If you could get something else thrown in with the Barber Id trade. I like Exquisite better then the crappy design of Playoff Contenders from last year.

[the1mcjensen]

if its your one and only, why do you keep trying to trade it?

[jstump37]

shap6761 Wrote:what card would you rather have

1) Adrian Peterson Playoff Contenders RC Ticket Auto (BV = $600)

2) Marion Barber Exquisite RC Auto #/150 (BV = $450, and quickly rising)

I am just curious... This is the third thread (I know of) where you are trying to trade away your Peterson Contenders rc. The one in your sig, announced by the title --

My One and Only AP Auto!!!!!!!

Don't you want it? I mean seriously, that's a real beauty, and until someone offers you more than book value for it, I wouldn't even consider trading it, but yet you come on here asking for advice each time someone makes an offer. Or are you going out and seeking/making offers so you can get rid of it?

[shap6761]

jstump37 Wrote:

shap6761 Wrote:what card would you rather have

1) Adrian Peterson Playoff Contenders RC Ticket Auto (BV = $600)

2) Marion Barber Exquisite RC Auto #/150 (BV = $450, and quickly rising)

I am just curious... This is the third thread (I know of) where you are trying to trade away your Peterson Contenders rc. The one in your sig, announced by the title --

My One and Only AP Auto!!!!!!!

Don't you want it? I mean seriously, that's a real beauty, and until someone offers you more than book value for it, I wouldn't even consider trading it, but yet you come on here asking for advice each time someone makes an offer. Or are you going out and seeking/making offers so you can get rid of it?

I was just curious if the Barber has more potential, that's all.

[shezdoni]

He's almost like that kid on the basketball boards that puts the lebron/jordan dual auto up for trade at least 3 times a day, then never trades it, even though he is offered cards he says he wants.

[jstump37]

No, Barber doesn't have as much potential. They will still be using RBBC in Dallas. One Jones left and another came in. People think Barber can carry the load, but he has yet to prove it. Between the two, who do you think will end up with more rushing yards in their career? I'm in the Peterson camp on that one. I can see Peterson being an MVP-type player. I just don't think Barber will even be close to that, ever.

But you still didn't answer my question. Why are you so anxious to trade away your great card?