I actually did this a while ago and here is what I got.
What I tried to do was think of the actual card and not necessarily the value of said. Some cards are on my list because of how I got it, what I paid for it or, simply put because I liked the card. Here are the results.
It is almost obligatory that this is #1
#2- I pulled it on Christmas morning from wax from my wife. Enough said.
#3 Love the concept of the card
#4 Love the aesthetic of this card
#5 Yup, its a base card....and one of the best designs I Can remember
#6 Paid $10 for this at a card show
#7 I don't quite remember where I got it or when but happy I did.
#8 Got this from a trader here. GREAT CONCEPT by Panini.
#9 Yup, its Off-centered. I don't care. I need it for my Base project.
#10 I have the Gold version as well which books for more. This one looks nicer though with the purple.
Thoughts? Opinions? Trolling? Whatever.
Want More? Check out my bucket. I have cards labeled 11-15 as well as 35 others that round out my top 50.
Since I originally posted this thread I have also added the Gold Standard Kobe Metal card, a relic /10 and his 2010-11 Donruss auto.