[blackitalian]

if you had the choice which one would you choose?

[nyyankeesfan28]

First one, only because it is a higher grade. If they were graded the same, I couldn't decide.

[uvaspina]

Hard to go wrong with either one. Aesthetically, I kind of prefer the 1910. I like the fact that he's holding a bat, and the background looks cool. I haven't looked up the values, so I'm assuming they're in the same ballpark.

[dallas_collecter84]

I would take the first one because he is actually doing something in the picture and the other is just a portrait. Having either one of those though would be amazing.

[mgruber2]

Green

[98holiday]

I like the look of the first one better.

[jacobystealshome]

2nd one for me. the more iconic of the two

[Neifert]

Don't think you can go wrong but I'd also pick the 1st one.

[cweiland]

I would pick the first one if it was me. Both are nice tho.

[ricelynnevans75]

Easily the green portrait.