[uvaspina]

(10-14-2012 09:56 AM)tntmclmm Wrote:  I wouldn't drop Stanton. I think he's a modern day Dave Winfield with the potential to hit for a little higher average. I think you always want a few up and comers in your pc. And if your talking only 5 pc players I wouldn't drop anyone. I cut a few because I pc 22 players and it was getting a bit much.

22! That's crazy! It's hard enough for me to stay on top of a few. -There are guys I collect on the periphery- mostly ones to round out a trade (Posey, Jeter, Kemp, Matt Moore, etc.) but I'm usually just looking for bait to get what I need.

[piyn]

I generally try to pick up as many Tigers cards as I can. Hopefully soon finacially I'll be set to start picking up cards again. When i do I've been thinking about trying to pick up more Max Scherzer and possible Drew Smyly cards. I think Smyly could become a good starter for us and replace Porcello especially if they keep Sanchez.

[toddaray]

Since it appears you are a Detroit fan, I would, without even blinking, get rid of your stantons. Being a Tigers fan you are almost NEVER going to have to root against two of them. But there may come a day, either in interleague play or a World series where Stanton destroys Verlander and I would in that situation feel terrible about ever collecting him in the first place. That said, I am probably the only collector who is as superstitious about my cards as I am the game itself.

[nyyankeesfan28]

From your pic and sig, you look like a Tigers fan, so drop Stanton. Also, wait a little to buy Cabrera cards, as the prices are inflated now.