[franciscomarina]

There is no complaining with an Allen & Ginter Mike Kelly card. A great looking card. Congratulations.

[krykslr]

If you're really unhappy with it, you can always just give it to me

Nice card man.

[rinzler]

Any VG grade implies there is a crease. Unless the edges are very bad (shows paper damage like a scrape), I think it should have been at least an EX. I hate these 'tweener grades.

[cdillon17]

(08-27-2012 04:51 PM)rinzler Wrote:  Any VG grade implies there is a crease. Unless the edges are very bad (shows paper damage like a scrape), I think it should have been at least an EX. I hate these 'tweener grades.

I don't think VG implies there is a crease. I think it implies there *may* be a crease. Unless I'm missing it, I don't see any crease.

[cdillon17]

I just stumbled on to the following eBay auction - http://www.ebay.com/itm/1887-Allen-Ginte...7675.l2557

Can someone tell me how my card (the one I posted scans of in this thread) and this card are graded the exact same?

---

I went ahead and made a picture showing both cards side by side:

[jstbuch]

I just love this set. I really want to put some of these old Allen Ginter sets together. Beautiful card!!!

[elberson]

Sweet card

[rmpaq5]

That is a beautiful card no matter your grade. I can see what you are saying based upon comparison your card seems to have better corners and sides. I am no professional grader, but to be fair (and it may be the camera or cameras if you consider both photos) there looks to be a colour difference between the cards. Perhaps the other card has better original colour and yours is faded?

(03-29-2013 08:01 AM)cdillon17 Wrote:  I just stumbled on to the following eBay auction - http://www.ebay.com/itm/1887-Allen-Ginte...7675.l2557

Can someone tell me how my card (the one I posted scans of in this thread) and this card are graded the exact same?

---

I went ahead and made a picture showing both cards side by side:

[duck6700j]

Great card no matter the grade.Think it could have been higher, maybe you caught the grader on a bad day.If you decide to resubmit it keep us posted.