[mancitylover111]

Do you think even with this edge damage if everything else looks good I could still pull a 9.5 on this 1993 SP Jeter Rookie?

LOOK AT THE WHITE ON BOTTOM LEFT UNDER GOLDISH WRITING

[ricelynnevans75]

Doubtful. The foil cards in that set have to be some of the most condition sensitive of the last 20 years.

EDIT: Is that some white on the edge going into the blue section as well? From what I've read over the years, that whole blue corner area is a killer........along with any potential scratches that might be lurking on the surface, which sometimes can be VERY hard to see.

[gangstippie]

A 9.5 will be tough. If you can see it, They definitely can under magnification. Get a jewelers magnifier and check all over it for any imperfections. You can get them for around 5 or 6 bucks online.

[kata78]

A 9.5 will be tough. If you can see it, They definitely can under magnification. Get a jewelers magnifier and check all over it for any imperfections. You can get them for around 5 or 6 bucks online.

I agree. I've sent in a couple that looked great with no chipping or white showing on the blue corner. They all came back as BGS 9's. So tough to get a 9.5. If it does come back a 9 you can always sell it for $350 and put it towards a 9.5