(07-15-2012 12:57 PM)blackitalian Wrote: Im talking about cut autos like the leaf oval office, mystery cuts, and the ones upper deck has where its a cut auto put into a card holder and marked 1/1. youre right if it was a auto directly on the card of course itd be more valuable and id understand the high prices, but when its just a cut on a index card or piece of paper and labeled 1/1 by these companies then how is that any more valuable then just buying a regular cut auto??? for example..you can buy a cut auto of hank aaron for around $100-$200, but because a company puts a cut auto and marks it 1/1 because they decided to only make 1 now all the sudden its worth hundreds more?? thats just plain stupid. the fact is its still a cut auto with or without the case.
(07-15-2012 01:15 PM)jacobystealshome Wrote: thats the case for any kind of auto then. by your theory, if a player signs a sticker, then the company puts it on a card, and it's related parallels, in your eyes, the cards with that sticker auto should be worth the same if it is numbered to 100 or 1, because duh, same sticker
and further, that also goes for ANY parallel, auto or not
(07-15-2012 01:11 PM)nolan5000 Wrote: Maybe these aren't for you.
(07-15-2012 01:44 PM)blackitalian Wrote: No because most of the time they only make a limited number of that particular card in variations ex. refractor, super-refractor, etc. so the card has its own value, then the auto raises the value. but when it comes to CUT autos, NOT ON CARDS, the value should be no different. I saw a guy pull a "1/1" babe ruth auto from a pack and try to sell it for 6k. You can buy a babe ruth cut auto for way less than that. so what im saying is a CUT AUTO IS SIMPLY A CUT AUTO. Just because a card manufacturer decides to put that cut auto in a case and say its a 1/1 how does that make it anymore valuable or different than any other cut auto???
(07-15-2012 01:58 PM)blackitalian Wrote: [quote='jacobystealshome' pid='2069672' dateline='1342381824']
whats the difference between a sticker auto and a cut auto
Nothing at all except a sticker auto is signed on a sticker and a cut auto is signed on a piece of paper or index card. thats pretty obvious
(07-15-2012 02:00 PM)jacobystealshome Wrote: exactly. so go back to my point above.
either one os slapped onto a card (or into)_, and variations are thusly produced
if cut autos are not worth more, because they are all just cut autos, the same goes for sticker autos
(07-15-2012 02:12 PM)bondssf2425 Wrote: My head is about to burst...Ok let me ask this question which would you rather own of your favorite player whomever it may be: a cut auto marked 1/1. or an auto on card from the same company in the same year that was numbered /50?
The cut auto is a piece of history that a company bought and crammed into a cardboard holder, most of them look mighty nice. I suppose I understand the feable premise that "all autos are 1/1" I dont buy it but I understand it, its the cut auto and the cardboard holder that it is so gently crammed into that create a combination that is rare or unique and causes such clammor for them. If you dont like it, dont pay 6k for one, sit back and laugh at the rest of us who get it, and spend your 6k on unnumbered items that go for $10 a pop and see how great your collection is.