[dbroockerd]

I have to decide in my roto league between Kershaw and Halladay. I can't keep both. It's auction so I can buy the other back.

I guess it does down to 2 things.
1. Whose the better keeper for this year and future years?
2. Who will be cheaper to reaquire?

[motu79]

Kershaw would be my opinion. He's younger, and I feel his division doesn't have as many good hitting teams like the NL East does.

[keyser soze]

I agree with Motu79. Kershaw's age is the deciding factor for me, and he'll probably also put up better numbers.

[dbroockerd]

Wow! Not what I expected to hear.

[keyser soze]

That's interesting that you expected to hear that Halladay was the better option. Kershaw had a better ERA, better WHIP, more K's, more Wins, and is 11 years younger

[dbroockerd]

That's interesting that you expected to hear that Halladay was the better option. Kershaw had a better ERA, better WHIP, more K's, more Wins, and is 11 years younger

Yeah I know. Guys tend to side with the proven. I think Howard's injury is a factor too. I just wondered who'd be cheaper really to buy back. I am keeping Kershaw I think for sure. He fits well with Lincy, Cain, and Romero.

[keyser soze]

Man, nice rotation! That competes with my rotation in one of my keeper leagues, I have Justin Verlander, Matt Moore, Josh Johnson, Ubaldo Jimenez, and Justin Masterson

[corbin21]

My vote for is Kershaw as well. He is in a very weak division, the Phillies will have no offense this year. There team is too hurt and too old. The Dodgers are on the rise where the Phillies are on the decline. And you will be able to buy Halladay on the cheap by the All-star break.

[dbroockerd]

Man, nice rotation! That competes with my rotation in one of my keeper leagues, I have Justin Verlander, Matt Moore, Josh Johnson, Ubaldo Jimenez, and Justin Masterson

I have Jurrjens to but not sure he will be worth a hoot. He is able to be kept at $5 though so I am happy to risk it. I dealt for Lincecum last night. I lose Halladay or Kershaw cause both made top 50 and I can only keep one.