[onemanstanding]

And that is a problem in their procedures they should at least give one day to dispute any issues and then ship the next day. The scans make them look worse then that actually are. Here is my submission a few months back.

6951077 2010 Certified Certified Potential Autographs Mike Kafka/50 9.0
6951078 2010 Classics Significant Signatures Platinum Mike Kafka/25 9.5
6951079 2010 Classics Significant Signatures Platinum Mike Kafka/25 9.5
6951080 2010 Donruss Elite Rookie NFL Shield Autographs Mike Kafka 10.0
6951081 2010 Donruss Elite Rookie NFL Shield Autographs Mike Kafka 9.5
6951082 2010 Donruss Elite Rookie NFL Shield Autographs Mike Kafka 9.5
6951083 2010 Donruss Elite Rookie NFL Shield Autographs Mike Kafka 9.5
6951084 2010 Donruss Elite Rookie NFL Shield Autographs Mike Kafka 9.5
6951085 2010 Donruss Elite Rookie NFL Team Logo Autographs Mike Kafka 9.5
6951086 2010 Donruss Elite Rookie NFL Team Logo Autographs Mike Kafka 9.5
6951087 2010 Donruss Elite Rookie NFL Team Logo Autographs Mike Kafka 9.5
6951088 2010 Playoff Contenders Mike Kafka GJ AU RC-(green jersey) 9.5
6951089 2010 Playoff Contenders Mike Kafka WJ AU RC-(white jersey) 10.0
6951090 2010 Rookies and Stars Longevity Mike Kafka AU 9.5
6951091 2010 Rookies and Stars Rookie Patch Autographs Blue NFL Logo Mike Kafka/22 10.0
6951092 2010 Rookies and Stars Rookie Patch Autographs Blue NFL Logo Mike Kafka/22 10.0
6951093 2010 Rookies and Stars Rookie Patch Autographs Blue Team Logo Mike Kafka 9.5
6951094 2010 Topps Platinum Autographed Patches Mike Kafka/800 9.5
6951095 2010 Topps Platinum Autographed Patches Red Refractors Mike Kafka 9.0
6951096 2010 Topps Triple Threads Printing Plates Cyan Mike Kafka JSY AU 9.0

[giantfan270]

That is insane! With my group submissions I have had over 1,000 cards graded, and still no 10's....

[onemanstanding]

And with that submission I assumed I knew what I was looking for, I am going to fight this and Beckett will either refund my money or allow me to resubmit these cards free of charge. I really believe these were graded unfairly. There are many others that I have issues with, but I am wondering if they somehow got damaged in their possession and now are slabbed for life.

[Num1Monroefan]

If you would have sent to BCCG you wouldn't have gotten just a 10, quite possibly a 12

[cybertrenz02]

Ill take the McFadden ...

[onemanstanding]

Here are the cards with their grades

Centering Grade : 9.5
Corner Grade : 9.0
Edges Grade : 9.5
Surfaces Grade : 9.5
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 9.5


Centering Grade : 9.5
Corner Grade : 9.0
Edges Grade : 10.0
Surfaces Grade : 10.0
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 9.5


Centering Grade : 9.5
Corner Grade : 9.0
Edges Grade : 10.0
Surfaces Grade : 9.5
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 9.5


Centering Grade : 8.0
Corner Grade : 9.0
Edges Grade : 9.0
Surfaces Grade : 9.5
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 8.5


Centering Grade : 9.5
Corner Grade : 9.0
Edges Grade : 9.5
Surfaces Grade : 10.0
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 9.5


Centering Grade : 9.5
Corner Grade : 8.0
Edges Grade : 9.0
Surfaces Grade : 9.0
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 8.5


Centering Grade : 9.0
Corner Grade : 9.0
Edges Grade : 9.0
Surfaces Grade : 9.5
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 9.0


Centering Grade : 8.0
Corner Grade : 8.0
Edges Grade : 8.0
Surfaces Grade : 9.0
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 8.0


Centering Grade : 8.5
Corner Grade : 9.0
Edges Grade : 9.5
Surfaces Grade : 9.0
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 9.0


Centering Grade : 9.0
Corner Grade : 8.5
Edges Grade : 9.0
Surfaces Grade : 8.0
Autograph Grade : 9.0
Final Grade : 8.5

---

Continued
Centering Grade : 9.5
Corner Grade : 5.5
Edges Grade : 9.0
Surfaces Grade : 9.5
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 6.0


Centering Grade : 8.5
Corner Grade : 8.0
Edges Grade : 7.5
Surfaces Grade : 9.5
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 8.0


Centering Grade : 9.5
Corner Grade : 8.5
Edges Grade : 9.0
Surfaces Grade : 9.0
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 9.0


Centering Grade : 9.0
Corner Grade : 9.0
Edges Grade : 9.0
Surfaces Grade : 10.0
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 9.0


Centering Grade : 9.0
Corner Grade : 8.5
Edges Grade : 9.0
Surfaces Grade : 9.5
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 9.0


Centering Grade : 9.0
Corner Grade : 8.0
Edges Grade : 9.5
Surfaces Grade : 10.0
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 8.5


Centering Grade : 9.0
Corner Grade : 7.0
Edges Grade : 9.0
Surfaces Grade : 9.5
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 7.5


Centering Grade : 9.0
Corner Grade : 8.0
Edges Grade : 8.5
Surfaces Grade : 9.5
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 8.5


Centering Grade : 8.5
Corner Grade : 8.5
Edges Grade : 9.0
Surfaces Grade : 9.5
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 8.5


Centering Grade : 9.5
Corner Grade : 9.0
Edges Grade : 9.0
Surfaces Grade : 9.5
Autograph Grade : 10.0
Final Grade : 9.0

[Num1Monroefan]

How does the David Nelson Contenders get a 8 on the centering and it looks fine while the Nelson NT gets a 9.5 on the centering when its clearly well off

[onemanstanding]

grades then the card

[sevans1979]

And with that submission I assumed I knew what I was looking for, I am going to fight this and Beckett will either refund my money or allow me to resubmit these cards free of charge. I really believe these were graded unfairly. There are many others that I have issues with, but I am wondering if they somehow got damaged in their possession and now are slabbed for life.

My thoughts also. I have heard of people's cards getting damages in shipping or in the hands of beckett and they just went ahead and graded them.

[giantfan270]

My thoughts also. I have heard of people's cards getting damages in shipping or in the hands of beckett and they just went ahead and graded them.

Happened to one of Lump's 1/1's when we did a group submit. Thank God he had pics from before and after. I couldn't even imagine how they damaged a corner so bad.