(11-29-2011 02:42 PM)kurtanglerookieyear Wrote: PSA 10 = BGS 9.5. No one makes any bones about this issue and it is fully understood in the market.
The two posters criticizing BGS seem to have an agenda and I don't buy it. One stop on feebay and it's plain as day that a BGS 9.5 is much more coveted than a PSA 10. And quite frankly, I'm sick of seeing 80's hockey psa 10's with edges that look like a bandsaw.
You can make the argument that vintage collectors prefer PSA for their history and their reputation with older sportscards. But there is no doubt whatsoever that modern collectors prefer BGS.
(12-06-2011 02:02 PM)sonnyday Wrote: I think there are more PSA collectors out there. I am one of them. I have a few BGS cards that are 9.5's but I like having a PSA 10.
With a 9.5 it means that there is something better lurking out there. But a PSA 10 is the highest grade by PSA, so people can brag they have perfection.
(11-29-2011 10:59 PM)rusty222 Wrote: Well I won't deny I may have an agenda but I still stand by my previous post. There was just a PSA 10 that just sold for $400+ with many different bidders while the bgs 9.5 same card listed for $199 cannot get a single bid. This is not uncommon either. Everyones entitled to his/her own opinion of course. Attaching flee bay links in case anyone has doubts.
I buy the BGS 9.5 and have it regraded as a PSA 10 its an automatic $200 profit.
I realize selling price is not everything , true collectors are not in this to sell and make money. I'm just pointing out the disparity in market values and PSA 10 own BGS 9.5 - modern card AND vintage.
(12-06-2011 02:08 PM)nolan5000 Wrote: I completely disagree!! There something out there better than a PSA 10. It's called a BGS 10!!
(12-06-2011 04:09 PM)sonnyday Wrote: I said psa 10 is the highest grade psa makes, therefore there is nothing higher then a psa 10 from psa. And can you say with 100% guaranty that a psa 10 would not grade bgs 10?
(12-06-2011 04:31 PM)nolan5000 Wrote: No, but I'd say it's slim to none. Especially after its bounced around in that PSA slab.
(12-06-2011 06:24 PM)sonnyday Wrote: So in my mind, there is doubt whatsoever that the modern collector prefer PSA.
(12-06-2011 06:33 PM)nolan5000 Wrote: How interesting. With this sentence you just contradicted yourself.