[kwikford1969]

Hello, recently got taken in a deal for these two cards and the trader won't do anything so wondered if anyone has any use for these as I dont. I'm going to leave them negative feedback and I figure he'll do the same for me so I'll hang up trading for awhile after this. Thanks to all the great I dealt with in the past and lately.

[evolb909]

If they were listed as mint the other trader should at least send you something else to compensate. What did you part with for them?

[lottyseanp1]

Not so bad...check me for both..

[kwikford1969]

(08-03-2011 04:45 PM)evolb909 Wrote:  If they were listed as mint the other trader should at least send you something else to compensate. What did you part with for them?

Couple of Ryan Braun (Brewers) autos.

[radarblip]

You would not believe some of the Damaged stuff I've seen come right out of packs and many are not replaceable. Quality Control?

Most companies will try to do something for you but it will generally be a replacement card, sometimes not even the same sport.

[dbroockerd]

I am interested, I don't think they are that bad.

[david campos]

If both sides of a deal aren't satisfied, the trade should be reversed, especially if he isn't willing to replace the damaged cards. I receive damage cards occasionally and make sure to notify the other trader immediately when it happens. Every time we agree to replace the damaged card and/or I send it back for something else.

[dbroockerd]

(08-04-2011 04:09 AM)david campos Wrote:  If both sides of a deal aren't satisfied, the trade should be reversed, especially if he isn't willing to replace the damaged cards. I receive damage cards occasionally and make sure to notify the other trader immediately when it happens. Every time we agree to replace the damaged card and/or I send it back for something else.

I agree with this. You should always be happy.
I am saying I would trade for the cards though. Just to make myself clear, I am not saying you are wrong. The trader should have fixed this.

[kwikford1969]

(08-03-2011 08:32 PM)lottyseanp1 Wrote:  Not so bad...check me for both..

trade offer sent

---

(08-04-2011 04:02 AM)dbroockerd Wrote:  I am interested, I don't think they are that bad.

thanks for the input, does anyone think they should be traded as "mint". Mint to me is a card would receive a BGS grade between 9 and 9.5. Do I need to change my thinking because 99% of the cards I get from everyone looks pack pulled with no problems.

[dbroockerd]

(08-04-2011 04:26 AM)kwikford1969 Wrote:  trade offer sent

---

thanks for the input, does anyone think they should be traded as "mint". Mint to me is a card would receive a BGS grade between 9 and 9.5. Do I need to change my thinking because 99% of the cards I get from everyone looks pack pulled with no problems.

I think most people don't adjust the grade on cards unless they are vintage. I would recommend always asking. If they lie then that is one thing, but if they send a decent card and you never asked they may have not thought twice about it. Some people, especially on autos, are not looking at it for grading. I never grade so I am not looking for PRISTINE or anything. I don't accept white dinged corners, bad edges, or chunks in the card, etc. This isn't likely an oversite though, but it happens.